Precaución
by lei_73

Comment:
Love the balance of the composition and the absurdity of the elements. Well processed, too. Nicely "arty".

Thither
by markwiley

Comment:
Why does this feel so much like a Magritte to me? Perfect for an art challenge. I love it.

'I still remember the day my father took me to the Cemetery of Forgotten Books for the first time.'
by lei_73

Comment:
My stand alone 10, I had three 9's. I thought this one was beautiful in all the ways everyone else has mentioned: lighting, expression, location and pose, look of the boy including costuming, tones, fit to the line and story. So wonderfully done. Congratulations.

4.3
by jmritz

Comment:
Boring to me - like our winter. Sorry. Gave this a four and I don't think you'll get much more. 4.25

7... 7... 7... 7... :))
by Mond

Comment:
Well . . . the inclusion of the joker made me laugh. I'd have scored this a lot higher if it didn't have this dirty look. I gave it a four but it may score closer to a 4.9.

5.82
by vawendy

Comment:
I think your guess is pretty accurate. I only gave it a five because for me there's too much light on the mouse and I really wish it looked more real. Predict a 5.75 or maybe even closer to your guess.

5.1266
by 2mccs

Comment:
This one has so much more potential imo. Most notably I would crop the right figure off and lighten the face so we can see his expression better. As it is, I can imagine. Gave it a five but maybe I'll come back to bump. Predict 5.75

6.0714
by markwiley

Comment:
I love the expressions and want to know the story - what are they looking at? And why is the center subject so startled or disturbed looking while the others, esp the one on the right, are so blase. I would be much closer to your score if it wasn't for the tones, light, on the center subject's face. Very distracting whether it was blown in the taking or in the processing. I gave it a five. Guessing 5.4

four
by posthumous

Comment:
Icicles, I think, but it looks for all the world like a very menacing male figure walking - toward or away from me, I'm not sure. Five from me for the eerie feeling. Predict closer to your guess. 4.3

6.1
by Drake

Comment:
The light and clarity are nice. I like the tones. That said, this is not interesting to me. Went with a five. I don't think it will hit your guess. 5.6