Wheels of Time FE/26 Iron
by MAK

Comment:
This is my favorite shot of the challenge. So much going on, yet shot and processed perfectly.
Beautiful image.
Love the idea.
Great composition.
Very well done!!!

Bumping to a 9

Lady of the Rings
by Judi

Comment:
I have read about those rings and "neck stretching". I couldn't imagine doing that. They ruin their muscle tone by doing this and from what I've read, it's not reversible... the damage is permanent. But, in the culture, they don't plan on reversing it... so I guess it doesn't matter much to them.

I love seeing different culture, which is why I would LOVE to travel all over the world.

This shot reminds me of when women wore corsets and kept taking it in.
It's amazing what we do for "beauty" and "culture".

As for the shot... I'm not feeling the white shirt on white background... her upper body seems to "disappear" into the background. Also, it seems a tad bright. But... overall, I like the concept shown here.

Coming back to vote

Size is Everything
by glad2badad

Comment:
OMG... this is beyond funny!
I see the proportion in this shot... but... this is just hilarious!
Maybe I just need to get my mind out of the gutter.
I love this!
It shows great proportion and is comedic at the same time!
Not to mention, the focus is great, the lighting seems good... everything seems in order in this shot.

I'm giving this a 10!

perfectly proportioned
by Giles

Comment:
I'm all for boudoir photography...
However, this is not "my" idea of perfectly proportioned. A little more "junk in that trunk" and I would say yes.

But... being said...
I love the crop on this shot. Great processing. Nice classic coloring. Her skin seems a tad too soft... but, great take on proportion!

Still giving this an 8

"To Have and Have Not"
by tvsometime

Comment:
Love the story in this photo. Take proportion to a different level. The old lady in the back seems to be a little overexposed... but nice candid shot.

Small Gains
by MinsoPhoto

Comment:
Love the processing here.
Great lighting.
Nice title.
Tells a wonderful story. Great job, love all the portraiture you've been doing.

Sign of the Iron Horizon
by crowis

Comment:
Too much PPing in this image. The horizon has a strange glow/halo to it. The picture is too dark overall, for my liking.
I'm thinking you were trying to show a lack of proportion in this shot?

Will come back to vote.

Cafe au lait
by Lawton

Comment:
I don't understand this shot?
There seems to be too much white.
THe draping and wrinkling of the material to the left of the frame is distracting. There are odd reflections in the items and the white balance appears to be off? Also, the specks on various areas are distracting.

Perhaps this was what you were going for... a non-proportional shot? I hope so, after writing what I just did.

If that was your attempt, then well done. You definitely ensured this was lacking proportion.

I will be coming back to comment.

Bar Graph
by GeneralE

Comment:
I like the idea here.
It seems a little overexposed on the left, and I'm not feeling the darkness of the tops of the tools.
It looks like it's OOF as well? Perhaps a handheld shot with some camera shake?

I do think it's a great concept, and I like the title...
I feel with a few adjustments, this shot could do well.

Coming back to vote

A Sense of Proportion
by vawendy

Comment:
Really like this silhouette shot! Wonderful portrayal of proportion.
My only criticism about this is the brightness (overexposure?) to the left of the frame on the water.
Other than that... It's a nice shot.
Will come back to vote.