Indigo City Morning
by DebN2003

Comment:
I think this shot would work much better in it's original form. The effects you added really ruin the overall picture for me. It meets the challenge without a doubt.

Market in Fall Rain
by DennisF

Comment:
Rural urban is the sense I get from this picture. I like that but the aspect of it, the angle is throwing me a bit but not in a bad way. The big white arrow on the right draws too much attention away from the buildings but at the same time makes you look at the overall picture.

Gothenburg By Night
by Mikael

Comment:
This is scoring low for me simply because the focus is way off, it's just a blur of lights to me, not a lot of definition and the balance between the sky and town is off. Too much negative space for this challenge.

Silos
by bigboy

Comment:
This does meet the challenge, it does convey that sense of urban but the colors seem off to me and the lines in the building actually make it look out of focus and distorted a bit, especially the ones on the silos themselves. The shot itself is well done, I like the cropping, the balance between the building and the sky.

Night N Day
by OOsiris

Comment:
This shot originally scored very low with me and upon second appraisal I will be raising my score but only by a few points. The angle of the shot really throws me and it if was a bit more level I probably would have liked it much better. The focus is too soft , more sharpness would have really worked on this for me. The sense of the challenge was met without a doubt, really conveys that sense of urban.

night and rain
by bleex

Comment:
Urban village, I love it. The picture itself is cropped well, I like the sense of being drawn over the bridge into the village. A bit more clarity would have raised your score a few more points for me. The light is a wonderful focal point.

Nature Retakes
by CraigD

Comment:
At first glance I thought you had gone for the nature landscape despite the title! But upon a second and closer look I now really see the building in the background and how it appears that it's being taken over by the tree but the ratios are slightly off, which actually adds to the picture for me. I am raising my original score but it could have been much higher if you had possibly cropped a little differently, brought the building in tighter, cutting out the right side would have worked for me, drawing more attention to the tree on the left

Urban Boat
by anireno

Comment:
This originally scored very low for me, it just didn't grab me at first glance but upon a second look I think it was the angle of the shot that originally threw me off. I see exactly what you mean by Urban Boat, it does look the bow of a ship. The antennea on the top adds the smokestack effect, very nice. The lighting and colors are excellent, this score goes way up on a second look.

Why is Harry Happy?
by dhelman

Comment:
I don't know why! :)

The lines on this photo help draw your attention accross the picture, which I do like but the lighting seems to be off. I'm guessing the store itself was in the shadows? And it seems just a bit grainy on my monitor.

Reflections from number 4
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
This is a very busy photo, so many things going on, so many things trying to draw your attention in, the hand rails going in all different directions offset by the straight lines of the building. Excellent capture of the chaos that can come from the urban area. The reflections really did throw me off at first but upon a second, longer look I see how they again, help convey the sense of chaos and busy aspect of the photo. Raising the score on this one for sure!