The American River
by ChrisW123

Comment:
Beautiful. But given we are lookng at what I suspect is the outside of a window, yet lookng out, I am guessing you brought this window to the site to shoot through it. In any case, it works well.

Walking in the woods
by heida

Comment:
This is laid out so well; colors, textures, light and the composition of the person in the frame. Nice work.

renegade
by sixgunwoody

Comment:
Cleverly done! Iove the selective colorization and concept.

Also in White
by Clarney

Comment:
Gorgeous capture of the cat through glass. This would have been even better IMHO if you cloned in the top border to complete the "frame". I am mixed about the water spots--the wet ones look good, the dry ones not so good.

Cat outside
by olnos

Comment:
Impressions: Beautiful pic of the cat; I like the tones here too.
Critical: Two issues I see: 1) the glare on the glass (a polarizer would help) and 2) no window frame visible per the challenge.

Evening View from Kitchen
by scottwilson

Comment:
Beautiful view, captured at a great time. I think it would have been stronger with 1) no inside lights on, to hide the kitchen stuff, and 2) more of a square positioning to the window frame.

Burnt Budweiser
by Shannon

Comment:
Interesting still life, well done. Perhaps some of the areas are just a bit on the bright/hot side (stick in foreground for example).

Golf Bridge
by Shannon

Comment:
A good composition; I think this would be a good one to visit on a cloudy day where the exposure can be better controlled as well as having a more interesting sky.

No Hunting
by Shannon

Comment:
A good shot; I would suggest straightening it so the pole is vertical and the horizon is level.

Closed Forever
by neilmwilson

Comment:
This was a pretty original idea. Perhaps you haven't looked at it closely enough though. There's a big margin between the car and background where you darkened or otherwise processed one differently than the other. Same by the mirror. You should make sure you do your editing in zoomed in -- very fine resolution mode which will give you more accuracy.