Just a man and his guitar
by SharQ

Comment:
Nice guitar capture; the movement capture is a good idea, but seems more "blurry" than movement blur. Looks like too little DOF (I do understand it was dark there). As to the challenge theme, an electric guitar is "electronic" and not very low tech!

Rubber & Steel
by phobden

Comment:
Yes, those are low tech office goods, nice color contrasts too. Works somewhat as a geometric abstract. But I think this could have been arranged and shot even more creatively.

8mm... pre-camcorder.
by notonline

Comment:
Nice idea for the challenge. This would have shown much better though with a black background, and maybe some more diffuse lighting. Perhaps a bit of a perspective shot would have been cool as well--that's a big lens for that camera!

Before FM
by Bela45

Comment:
I like the angle you shot this at, the colors and soft look you've captured. I'm not exactly sure what I'm looking at: either an old radio or shortwave radio, I presume. I think stepping back a bit (or cropping less) might have helped me identify it more quickly. My own views aside, but you are probably taking a beating on this as this is an electronic device (challenge said non-electronic). But it's stil a nice photo (and I scored it well anyway.)

Spinning Wheel ~ Hi-Tech 700 Years Ago
by hyperfocal

Comment:
Very nice lighting, good capture of the motion, and good idea. The only thing that might have improved this in my eyes is the inclusion of an operator.

Antique Iron
by Bud

Comment:
Very cool device (or very hot!). Great for Low Tech. Capture is very good, lighting is good, but I think the composition is a bit cramped at the left, and also, but less so, at right and bottom. I think stepping back and capturing a bit more negative space would have worked here.

The abacus
by Jinjit

Comment:
I was thinking about an abacus for this challenge--good idea. I like the dark background and the lighting; I think it could have been made more interesting perhaps by spreading out the balls as if a calculation were being performed.

simple and happy
by saintaugust

Comment:
Cute shot, simple low tech device. I like the high key here, and the angle. I am more mixed about the foreground texture--is this sitting on a bedspread?

Claremont Harvest
by Chubba

Comment:
Nice! I like the use of the sillouette here, and the sunset and sky adds mood, but the barn/shed/whatever on the left is a distraction in sillouette form. I think it might have worked better with just the pulley device.

"Ye Olde Nutcracker"
by Tressider

Comment:
Cool instrument and I love the warm tones. You may not have noticed but there's some stray light on your background on the right edge and at the top right of the nut cracker. Looks like bottom left too but less so on my monitor. Compositionally, this misses for me; I think it might have worked better either in portrait format, or back a step, with the nuts in the foreground not "clipped", and perhaps on the left third line. Or maybe a more diagonal layout of the extra nuts--walking down the diagonal from one sweet spot to another.