Sunset Bridesmaid
by DavidSharp

Comment:
I like the overall feel of this photo, but for this particular challenge I think the focus should have been on the girls legs not the car wheel.

Father I am on my knees for you!
by NattieJ

Comment:
A bit of a stretch for me, and I'm not sure I am a fan of the bluish hue and the diagonal crop.

Filling Dad's shoes
by LonnieD

Comment:
Cute idea. Technically a bit to pixely for me, and a bit out of focus.

Tribute to Tim Lincecum - First of Fourteen Strikeouts
by pastortimmr

Comment:
There have been other photo's in this challenged cropped like this, I'm not a huge fan. It makes me think you are just using a picture you already had and cutting it in half to make it work for the challenge. I think this picture would have been much more interesting with the faces in it but then it wouldn't have worked for the challenge.

Which Knee?
by reneekerr

Comment:
A bit too much of a stretch for me, almost like you made a picture you already had work for the callenge, instead of the other way around.

From The Knee ... uh ... Up?
by GeneralE

Comment:
very creative idea, technically though the shot could use some work, a bit grainy and out of focus.

Legs
by bjoern

Comment:
I like the shot, but I don't like that it looks like you took a regular shot and just cropped it in half. I think it would have been more sucsessful in a regular photo ratio.

Madison
by cellvian106

Comment:
This looks a little too much like you took a full length shot and cropped it in half. The soft focus doesn't help either.

toes
by kitkatklok

Comment:
Technically a good picture. I'm just not sure it fits the challenge.

Blue Toes
by tanguera

Comment:
Not a bad shot, technically I can't give you any critique. but her legs are in bad need of a shave or something and the toes are in need of a manicure. Now that I am looking closer, mabey that was your intent, I notice the dress is in need of an ironing as well. So mabey it was an overall look you were going for.