Voigtlander
by Neil

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 4, The light is killing you here, too direct, try to diffuse it more, to take the bright spots away from the edges.
Appeal: 6
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

Brace and Bit
by Diana

Comment:
Composition: 4, The brace looks out of place, boring a hole in a board next to the wall.
Technical: 4, Subject could be moved away from wall to disperse the strong shadow caused by your flash.
Appeal: 3, I would have tried to make a story out of this someway, maybe by adding a worker. Hell I don't know but it needs something to make it pop.
Challenge: 9
Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

Past Usefulness
by brooklyn

Comment:
Composition: 4, The hinge doesn't take command of this image, even with the desaturation.
Technical: 5, The single extra bright screw head just takes over. You need to subdue it.
Appeal: 4
Challenge: 7, The mechanical portion is not strong enough in this image.
Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

Only Time Will Tell
by TDCollins

Comment:
Composition: 7, I think it would look much better if it were straight with the frame.
Technical: 7, Not grainy, good capture with the subdued light.
Appeal: 5, Needs another factor. What are we timing..or something like that.
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

Oh the Drama
by sjoseph1

Comment:
Composition: 3
Technical: 2, Way too obscure, I cannot tell what it is, and I need to know.
Appeal: 1
Challenge: 6
Overall Calculated Average Score: 3

Simple Sissors
by jimmsp

Comment:
Composition: 4, Needs something else to support the main subject.
Technical: 5
Appeal: 3, Not enough here to spark my interest.
Challenge: 9
Overall Calculated Average Score: 5, In this case simplicity ended up being weak.

Old Reliable
by FirstAid

Comment:
Composition: 4, objects in upper part are distracting, would be better if done without them.
Technical: 4, The mechanical part seems to look like you oversharpened in post processing.
Appeal: 3, A difficult subject to make interesting enough to keep the interest of the viewer.
Challenge: 9
Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

For Whom The Bell Tolls
by plumber711

Comment:
Composition: 4, Nice but your background is too domineering.
Technical: 4
Appeal: 4, Doesn't keep my interest, lacking the WOW factor.
Challenge: 9
Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

Give it a Twist
by AChelton

Comment:
Composition: 2, Nothing done to get my interest,
Technical: 3, soft focus, IMO it should be sharp in this instance
Appeal: 2, Sorry, just another can opener
Challenge: 9, Can't deny that but lacks interest.
Overall Calculated Average Score: 4

Dusty mechanics
by Pascal

Comment:
Composition: 3, wires lead out of picture, no real main subject.
Technical: 2
Appeal: 1, Not interesting
Challenge: 1
Overall Calculated Average Score: 2, IMO missed the challenge completely