Around the fire
by jab119

Comment:
The joys of camping! I like this image, it has a nice story/mood to it. The campfire gives a great glow to the children and helps make the lighting look how my mind envisions a night of camping. I do wish there was a little more focus on both of the girls though. Also, the empty chair is a little distracting because its color is so vivid it draws my eyes away from the two girls (who I think are the focal point of the piece). Nice job! 6

First Light
by newtune3

Comment:
Beautiful sunrise. The colors are rich and contrast each other well. I love how sharp the clouds look and the fact that there isn't any significant glare to be seen. Very peaceful mood, excellent capture. 8

Sundown
by ellamay

Comment:
I'm obtuse sometimes and in this case I don't get the title, but I don't hold that against the piece. I'm very intrigued by this image. The lighting is excellent, I love the warm neutrals against the black. The detail and focus are perfect - the grain is very evident and that texture really adds to the photo for me. Its got very simple lines which lend its rough nature a bit of elegance. Wonderful image, very well accomplished. 9

Dark Industry
by Konador

Comment:
Beautiful colors and the light display is gorgeous. I like the contrast with the colors and the nature vs machine. The border keeps my eyes from wandering out. I do wish the light rays didn't extend onto the buildings on the left so much so they'd be a crisp black, but its hard to tell the sun what to do. ;) A very striking image. 7

Humber Bay Princess
by timmi

Comment:
Wonderful choice for interesting shapes and dynamics. The lighting is okay, I like how it is just barely lighting up the bridge's upper workings, though I wish it was stronger. The perspective is good, gives the bridge depth and breadth. I think the color could be richer, which would give the contrasting nature of the orangey brown and white a boost. A nice shot. 6

reflective tarp
by undieyatch

Comment:
This is a rather different subject. I see its connection to light and the light usage is good, makes use of the nature of the tarp. Colors have a nice contrast (wish they were a bit more vivid) and the focus is good. Unfortunately, I don't find the subject very interesting and that lack of influence does affect my voting. I think its a technically sound image, but a little boring. 6

"It's a beautiful life"
by kengurinn

Comment:
The child certainly looks carefree! I like the silhouette look and I always enjoy seascapes. Great use of space and light is what helps make this image, though the sun's rays are harsh and slightly unappealing. I definitely get a happy go lucky feeling from the image. Well portrayed. 7

Day Dreaming of Warmer Days
by scrum8

Comment:
I always like photos of eyes, they are one of the most expressive subjects. I am curious about your choice of title, only because I don't see a correlation with the picture and it - I wasn't sure if you were going for a reflection of a rainy day window in her eyes and that's where it came from, because without the title I wouldn't think 'daydream' mainly because of the tight focus. BUT, I think this is a solid image. The lighting is good, focus is clear, particularly on the left (and well-lit) eye. Her freckles are adorable, gives the features a bit of precociousness. If the window reflection idea was correct, I think it needs to be a bit more evident, if not then ignore that part. ;) Well done. 6

1:19 AM
by Quadrajet

Comment:
Good use of light, I like the rays coming over the building. The difference in colors with the warm orange against the cooler grey/blue adds interest, as does the perspective. There does however seem to be some glare, flares or something.. little white bits in the sky, they don't look like stars (though they may be) but it is rather distracting and detracts from the image. 5 Revising my vote after due to further info from photographer, they are stars and knowing how they came about made a difference. Upgrading to a 6 because I now understand why they look as they do but still find them distracting .

crestfallen
by nborton

Comment:
I'm not sure where the title comes in play, though it looks kind of like he may be pouting? or sticking out of the tongue.... the crop may have removed that aspect. Great lighting on the jacket, marvelous detail. To be honest, I would suggest cropping out more of the left side, so that pout/tongue whatever isn't in the shot, just the jaw. I am finding my attention is captured very well by the detail of the jacket and his hands - a strong masculine image. 7