Spotted!
by KMcC

Comment:
Critique Club Review:

Color Saturation and Hue: Colors are not realistic, but do work very well with this composition.

Brightness and contrast: seems the highlights have been pulled way down and there is a lack of contrast

Focus and depth of field: the deer appear a bit soft but that could be part of the processing

overall its a nice image, its doens't overly appeal to my tastes but you captured a nice moment.

frogbaby
by posthumous

Comment:
critique club:

nice colors, i can make out the tadpole easy enough. not sure im big on the blown highlights as they tend to draw my eye away from the subject but knowing you that might be the intent :)

Protector
by Ja-9

Comment:
critique club:

you got second place so you know its a good image, i cant find much to dislike except maybe its a bit over sharpened for my tastes.

great details, composition and colors.

Mom + 1.5 Babies
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
critique club:

i'm not fond of this image, the subjects seem awkward and they lack that "cuteness" one expects from this moment. its not like you can pose them, though :)

the colors and details all seem to blend together and the background bleeds into the subject so there is isn't enough isolation of the subject to any appeal either.

Humpty Dumpty from Hell
by Pinkella

Comment:
critique club:

blacks are too black, the subject pops off the page nicely, the background is too busy to isolate the subject however and really adds a lot of unnecessary detail.

Good Weather For Shooting Mountains & Stars
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
critique club:

this is great. perfect tones and colors, i'd like to maybe see and bit more sky but i can't really find anything not to like here.

Good....morning sliver moon
by billyfredhuff

Comment:
critique club:

the horizon is crooked (or the house is). the color are nice, exposure could have been a bit longer to pick up the sky colors. Ultimately the image is too busy with a foreground that is too dark and busy.

take a bit more time and walk around to find a better composition or perspective.

Ahhhhhh Shiiiit....Now I'm in a bad trouble
by clickodak

Comment:
critique club:

nice concept, i'd like to see more of the image in focus but great b/w conversion with really nice tones.

~ faded rose from days gone by ~
by KMcC

Comment:
critique club:

really nice shot, clean, sharp, nice subdued colors, you could print this out and hang it on a wall. i dont have any advice on improving it... sorry :)

Fleeing Neutrinos
by Skip

Comment:
critique club:

this is an awesome firework shot. the colors are so not what you would expect from fireworks,its clean, sharp and the blacks are black. i'd maybe like to to see the center of the burst on the upper third point intersection but that's a minor picky complaint.