Steese Ice Tower
by grawk

Comment:
cool tower, the shot looks a little washed out on the left side but on the whole a very pleasing entry

Frozen Waterfall
by Shaman

Comment:
the top crop is poor, either give us some sky or cut it below the top of the ice & rocks

Riverbend
by bongo

Comment:
I know this comment won't help to make you a better photog, but... YES! this is my idea of a great AA entry, I hope people don't vote it down for not being totally B&W. The only flaw I can find is what looks like some ice floating near center bottom, maybe that could have been cloned out so the water's surface was more consistent

a photograph is made, not taken.
by fstopopen

Comment:
I don't see the great depth of field needed to do Ansel, the background looks flat, like a backdrop

Highway
by Jacko

Comment:
the use of dodge & burn is too obvious; over done, doesn't look natural; very good depth of field

Plain Perspective
by Simonjw

Comment:
wish you had moved one fince post forward

Snow white
by Anastasia

Comment:
Beautful image of a beautiful model, but the hair that partially blocks one eye has made it seem that they are not a matched pair, which in turn makes the shot seem out of balance, the darker eye draws the viewer's attention too much; I'd suggest a slight lightening of the exposed eye to bring it closer to the overall lightness of the picture. This should do well in the challenge.

Dreaming of Serenity
by cheekymunky

Comment:
the border is a bit heavy, a little more contrast would be an improvement in my eyes, but overall this is one of the better images in the challenge

tiger-moth.jpg
by megryan

Comment:
The border is ok, but any wider might look too heavy. The background is very good. The moth is in focus, sharpening and colors are right there. Well done.

Light On White and really light
by IceRock

Comment:
dnmc, but one of the best photos in it