Waiting for Use for Decades
by rlewis

Comment:
I didn't vote in that challenge and anyway my ratings are often the opposite of the mainstream so probably not much use to you but I like your image. I am no expert either so take this all with suitable doses of salt...

For me it has a sense of mood and generally good overall composition. I like the tonal range and narrow depth of field - they suit the composition and feel.

The only negatives I would raise are the chopped off (and therefore unresolved) bits of stuff in the bottom right foreground and mid right that are a little distracting (to me).

I would have rated it more than the ~4.7 and 97/133 you got - around 6-7 on my warped scale.

That is probably your downfall then... if I like it, many others won't :(

Dillo in the sky
by WalesP

Comment:
I think this has potential but wondering if the interesting bits (for me the top half of the image) wouldn't have been better if made more dominant.

The bottom half takes up a lot of image and the composition seems to aim the eye there but isn't that interesting - sorry had to give it 5 but personally think it could have been worth much more with a different angle of shot and cropping. Potential is there.

Dented
by Kelli

Comment:
good focus and colours but it doesn't really grab me. Maybe a tighter crop perhaps or more dramatic lighting? Not sure but can't see how to make this shot stand out but for me it just doesn't resonate - 5

Killer Sushi !!!
by mrbig65

Comment:
good colours and focus and imagination but it just doesn't hit me. It should!- the idea (I am guessing) based on the subject matter and arrangement is to provoke a response from the viewer but for some reason isn't doing that for me. I am wondering if it is a little to unsubtle... perhaps if you had panned back a bit so the shot at first glance looks like a fairly normal scene then forces a second glance to make the hit rather than the screws being pretty much in your face? Who knows... sorry but had to give it 5

"... and it even came with a built-in cupholder!"
by GeneralE

Comment:
sorry - it just doesn't happen for me, no criticism other than no 'impact'

give it 5

Still Life with Potato
by Lonni

Comment:
a well executed shot, colour focus composition etc properly done but... sorry it just doesn't have much impact for me :(
have to give it 5

Pirate Ship near a lake side Church
by amateurboi

Comment:
sorry - the image just doesn't grab me as particularly interesting so had to give it 4. No other criticism than no real impact for me.

Crossroads
by hahn23

Comment:
definitely meets the challenge but doesn't really resonate with me other than that. Focus and composition OK but not much spark. That is just me though - 5

Capsized?
by chazoe

Comment:
sorry it just doesn't strike me much this one. The point of interest is too small to make a strong statement I guess. Had to give it 4

Look out area
by whiterook

Comment:
sorry but this didn't grab me much - no emotional response. No technical criticism though - 4