l'heure bleue
by TrollMan

Comment:
Here I am again looking at a shot I scored low and wondering what I was thinking. I actually like this after looking again and again, it still isn't in my top picks but you have cleared your way from the low end. The ligh and shadows works nicely for this image and the trees are a nice addition.

The Wizardry of the digital age
by HighNooner

Comment:
You have some neat effects and processing going on in tis image but for me and my thoughts of Fine Art this just falls short. Good Luck.

4286 4286
by tfarrell23

Comment:
Everyones opinion on what constitutes Fine Art varries greatly and I believe our views do not see eye to eye on this entry. It is a fine shot but for me it just doesn't do it. Good Luck.

Nature's Recycling
by dtallakson

Comment:
Hmm... to bad you couldn't use this for the Branch challenge coming up. As far as for the Fine Art challenge, for me at least, this doesn't really protray that.

3:00 a.m.
by kolasi

Comment:
Personally I think this image would be stronger, and in my opinion on fine art would fit my definition better if the sign were to be eliminated from the shot.

Contemporary Hair Style
by BrianR

Comment:
Sorry but for me this really just seems like a portrait with nothing special and, imho, no Fine Art quality. May just be my opinion and the great, terrible, funny, crazy, stressful, interesting thing with art is our varying definitions. Good Luck.

no title
by Keith_W

Comment:
Originally this was a low vote from me but now that I have revisited it I like how it seems to be coming out of my screen and hanging down. A pretty cool effect. I also like the use of negative space. Bumping this vote up a bit now.

The Tears of Medium Density Fibreboard
by raish

Comment:
This really doesn't seem to be Fine Art, imho. Alas that is the curious thing about art, all of our definitions could vary drastically from one viewer to the next. Good luck.

negative space in a vertical world
by chalice

Comment:
Art is a funny thing in that while it has definitions, those definitions are different for each person either creating or viewing the art. I am sure you probably see this as an excellent interpetation as Fine Art but for me it doesn't convey my feeling or thought of what Fine Art is. Because of that I scored this low even though it is a well done photo.

To dawn, Eos greets Helios.
by wingyisleeds

Comment:
Originally this was a 2 from me. I am bumping it up because I actually though about entering something like a white canvas with a simple red line through it. This is something, imho, that you could run across in a modern art gallery. I am not giving it one of my top scores but it is going up quite a bit from the original 2. Good luck.