Fun in the Dressingroom
by RxP13

Comment:
This seems more like a snapshot capturing a fun memory for the participants than a photograph trying to spread an idea to strangers. They are certainly having fun, but I'm sorry to say it doesn't have much meaning for me.

root of all evils...
by imagesloyola

Comment:
At first glance, I'm reminded of the biblical allusion to money as the root of evil, but suddenly I notice how it's rolled to draw attention to the faces on the bills, so now think it's saying that politicians that are the root of all evils. Nice job.

One of Millions Sentenced to Die Yearly. Spay or Neuter Your Pet.
by jaimeegrl

Comment:
The dark tones and low contrast add to the message of this image.

No Child Left Behind......four days a week
by coolhar

Comment:
I don't know what the "four days a week" means, but the two buildings make a striking contrast.

Eat at Tony's, it's the best.
by bruski

Comment:
Advertising is a form of propoganda, and this looks delicious. Nice array of textures, although a bit soft; some sharpening would help them stand out more. Something green (a salad?) would have made a nice allusion to the Italian flag, but there is certainly plenty there without it.

Voyage Of Spirits
by amateurboi

Comment:
I'm not sure what idea this photo is trying to convey. But the image does catch the eye and the "spirit" has an interesting shape and texture (although there are some apparent specular highlights that are distracting).

CLICK TEN NOW!
by Paulk

Comment:
10? OK... Oops... Missed... Got the 1 instead... ;-)

Seriously, this photo clearly conveys your message, which is extra important for this challenge. Artistically, I wish you had done one more level so the bottom paper wouldn't be just white under the hand.

Back from a walk in the woods
by sergut

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club!

I really like this image. It has an inviting, warm, peaceful feeling. Your comment implies you wanted to portray coziness and you were successful. You've chosen quite a few compatible yet contrasting elements and arranged them very nicely, with multiple levels to add interest and realism. Good lighting, focus, and processing. The mildly low key tonality works very well.

Although a great photo, since you requested a critique I feel obligated to point out the few flaws. It seems tilted slightly clockwise (or perhaps the painting is just not straight; it has a lot of horizontal and vertical lines that aren't quite). There is some glare from the light on the right side of the painting. The linen has some distracting folds (a bit too realistic!).

Blue Cool
by Gracious

Comment:
Critique Club comment:

A striking image from a few simple elements nicely arranged with dramatic lighting. The black background creates a stark contrast that really grabs the viewer's attention. Although made of the same material, the Slinky and jacks have entirely different textures, providing some contrast, and there is a nice gradation of texture from the left to the right side of the Slinky. A couple of minor flaws: a bit cramped at the top and too much glare on the rightmost jack. But overall a nice image.

Attacked from all sides!!
by sknittel646

Comment:
Per your request from the Critique Club:

This is a humorous photo; it's easy to see that the pen is being attacked. For what it's worth, I wouldn't have even imagined a correlation to struggles in our own lives; even with your comment I have a hard time making the connection because of the whimsical nature of the photo. But that doesn't stop the photo from conveying a clear message, even if not the one you intended.

Unfortunately, the photo doesn't have much impact. It's elements don't contrast with each other enough. A black stapler with a textured finish and a harsher light to cast stronger, more distinct shadows would have been better. And here's a crazy idea: replace the background with a classic draped cloth like those used in traditional still lifes. I'm frankly not sure how that would affect the message, but it might be fun to try.