Barren
by tfarrell23

Comment:
I like this very, very much--and gave it a ten. However, I think the frame was a big mistake for this picture. It is a very soft picture, even with the tree. The frame keeps bringing my attention out of the picture and I'm finding it very distracting. I couldn't rate it down because of that, though, because I enjoyed the picture too much.

Fighting for Survival
by nidici

Comment:
Nice idea, but the tree really gets lost in the photo. Would a lower angle separate the tree from the background and give it a little more definition.

Tree at Grand Canyon
by zymara

Comment:
I like this very much, but I wish there was more definition to the tree. With the fog, I'd be happier with everything a little more washed out and get a little detail back on the tree.

Last Light
by SaraR

Comment:
I like this very much! I find it extremely pleasing for some reason--it just calls to me. I couldn't decide between 9 and 10, so I gave it a 10.

One small thing... It looked like you decided to crop it to a 5x7 proportion. I'm curious what it would have looked like if it was cropped in a little more from the right...

OAK OF AGES
by melissamp99

Comment:
Very nice tree; it has lots of character. however, I wish the tree fit in the frame. It gives the impression that you couldn't move back any farther (or zoom out), and that it just didn't fit. I'd either crop more or less.

Beautiful Beginning's
by Dominic146

Comment:
nice shot, fun idea.

Standing Alone
by J-Me

Comment:
I like the photo very much... however, the white glow behind the tree looks unnatural. If it was a fluke of nature, sorry! If you lightened it to bring the tree out, it's a little overdone.

overall still very nice!

Sepia dawn
by Yo_Spiff

Comment:
very nicely done!

Morning Frost
by Len Scap

Comment:
very nicely done!

Summer Shade
by GregoryB

Comment:
wonderful! but this is my favorite so far. (by quite a bit!) I love it being all shades of the same color. It's muted, yet the leaves still glow.