Grandpa's Tractor
by Lydia

Comment:
I love the top part of the photo, and I don't usually mind things disappearing, but I really think that on this shot, it would have been better to see the whole tractor. 6 for that lighting on the top, probably would have been an 8 if you had the whole tractor.

Only the lonely
by quiet_observation

Comment:
I'm wondering if you've done something like this before... It looks very familiar. Anyway, I think it's spectacular! 10

Equal spaces between
by hojop25

Comment:
sorry -- that's really pushing it, imo. I think you should be able to look a a picture and have a vague idea of what the challenge is about. I had no idea what your three was until I looked at the title. Imo, DNMC.

However, that being said, I think it's a very interesting, very intriguing photo. I wish it was in free study, or someplace that it fit a little more. So sorry!

Cycle-Shoe-Rescue
by drydoc

Comment:
I'm so sorry, but there's just too many subjects. I looked at the picture before I read the title, and I would have thought your subjects were the shoe, helmet and cycle, or perhaps shoe, cycle and truck. It really was more of an all things being equal: five.

Sorry, DNMC, imo.

2 ducks for 1 fish
by redpanda

Comment:
Couple of things:

nit pick -- the fish isn't really equivalent, he blends in, and I didn't particularly notice him until I read the title. It doesn't really affect my vote, however.

It seems very oversaturated on my monitor. And I wish the angle was a little more from the right so that you could see more than just the back of the female's head.

untitled
by eyeduphotos

Comment:
Great shot!! But then again, I'm partial to gulls... :)

Identical Flashlets
by daevans

Comment:
Would have liked this better without the reflections. They're so pale, it doesn't really add much interest, imo. Sorry!

Fish
by schugirl

Comment:
I'm sorry, but even though there are only three fish in the foreground, there is the fourth one in the back, and it actually draws the eye. I'm sorry, DNMC, imo.

Peanut Butter and Fluff Sandwich
by whiterook

Comment:
I'm sorry, but on my screen this is incredibly oversaturated.

Outside the fray
by glad2badad

Comment:
It's a great capture, but the partial head on the left and on the right are quite distracting. Nothing much you can do about it, but it lessens an otherwise interesting shot.