6.25
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
There's something very compelling about this one. seven from me. Guessing 6.05

6.4758
by Alain

Comment:
I think you'll get hit for looking out of the frame so close to the left. The right 1/3 of the picture doesn't do a lot for it, imo, and takes away from the overall. Also the vignette so close on the left closes it down. I think it would have worked much better if you had darkened the right side and not the left (in more of a gradual vignette). I'm guessing 5.65.

627 μs
by pamb

Comment:
Gorgeous shot -- wonderful capture! Guessing 6.7

6
by Judi

Comment:
Nice. I like the tones. I'm wondering if you'll get hit for the horizon being in the middle. Doesn't particularly bother me, but I'm guessing you're hearing it in the comments. :)

I'm guessin 5.95

Six (optimistic)
by kprasad9375

Comment:
I'm wondering if you'll get hit for being an oil outtake. I'm guessing 5.9

Caged Heat... 5.5
by RyanW

Comment:
The face says a lot, but I'm not sure of the composition. I don't know that looking out of the frame on the right works. I'm curious what it would have looked like with more of a square crop on the right and the face brightened a bit. With the light on the left side, it shows just how harsh the lighting is. With that cropped off and it lightened a bit, it would stand out so much that it's difficult lighting. Guessing 5.4

Five point 5
by GeorgesBogaert

Comment:
I like it. Seven from me, I'm guessing 6.15 from the collective

5,1551
by mrbig65

Comment:
I like the treatment on this. I'm curious whether or not it's tilted a tad to the left? Can't really tell.... I like that you kept the green on the left. I'm guessing 6.1

Ambush - 4.2
by rooum

Comment:
It seems like there's potential here, but it's somehow now quite right. The more I look at it, I'm curious what it would have looked like zoomed in on the smaller blue door almost obliterated by the tree... Six from me, but I think the overall will be more like 5.4.

5.3468
by timfythetoo

Comment:
I love the colors in this, and at first it seems very intriguing… but then it doesn't really seem to have anywhere to go. Strong initial impression, but they story seems to end there.

Composition-wise, I wish the person were at the right window looking out instead of centered. I really don't mind centered compositions, it's just that it feels a little claustrophobic, like there's not enough space. Doesn't make any sense, I realize, it's just the feeling that came to me. :)

I think it deserves a score higher than my guess, but I'm guessing 5.6 from the collective.