Tracks
by jodiecoston

Comment:
Strong angle shot! Challenge well met. Framing works for me. Focus seems pretty good. I always like a little bit of foreground material in scenery shots, so I like that tuft of grass in the lower right corner, nich touch. 8 Swash

Columbia
by tfarrell23

Comment:
Very strong image. Color seems very good. I'm not totally certain about how this relates to this challenge, but I'll not argue too much (I've been looking at so many high angle shots, this seems like a refreshing change). I don't understand your title, but that's nothing to do with your score either. (If you care to PM me, I'd be fine with that!) 8 Swash

A Window-cleaner's Nightmare
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
Wow, very clear shot with a good perspective subject (might work well for the Rythme challenge too). Color - the blue seems a little too saturated (too dark to be real), but that also may be a result of window tinting (well, it could!). You picked an interesting, but slightly difficult angle to view (still, it works for me). Did you de-staturate the bricks, or were they really this grey? (just asking, not a score issue)
8 Swash

Structures of an Old Factory
by nathaliedoo

Comment:
Very good perspective shot. Focus is good, lighting seems about right, color - hard to say, but I'll go with it. Interest - well, there's the rub...I'm not terribly fond of run down/old buildings, but I'll try to not let that sway my score. 8 Swash

A calm winter afternoon
by jjbeguin

Comment:
Beautiful scene. Sepia (it is Sepia, right?) seems very correct and effective here. Focus appears good, lighting works. Challenge well met. I feel another score bump coming! (I'm overcoming a bias on non-color photos!) from 8 to 9!! Swash

WWII-B36
by autool

Comment:
Very clear shot! This seems like a bit of an odd perspective, but it works for me. I don't remember seeing a push propeller bomber, must be a McDonald Douglas product (I work for Boeing, he he) Colro seems a tad low, esp. the yellow on the prop tips (a little washed out?) Otherwise, this is a very fine photo! 8 Swash

Twilight of Idols
by magnetic9999

Comment:
Very nice perspective shot! Focus is sharp, good amount of contrasts. Interest - pretty good, it's a dramatic view, I like it! Score bump! from 8 to 9! Swash

Silo
by Gekker

Comment:
Very sharp photo. Color seem very good, too. It works as a perspective shot, challenge met. My only nit is the sunflares on the left edge. 8 Swash

The Guardians
by DennisF

Comment:
Nice perspective shot. Central focus area is very clear/sharp. Good title. Interest level is moderate (but that's just me). 8 Swash

Windswept Pastures
by Tarbini

Comment:
WOW! Very postcard-ish. IMHO, the best of the challenge and my only 10. Color is outstanding! Framing is very good. Focus - very sharp. I like the cows meandering in the frame with their shadows. The windmills on the top of the hill, very, very nice! Nice contrasts. Did I say this was a 10? Swash