Different
by Clou9

Comment:
Interesting idea. IMO the background may have worked better if you outlined the tree shape (masked off the extra) and maybe ironed it flat. I'm a bit of a consistency freak, so I think I would have preferred the red balls all oriented the say way. Lighting - very inconsistent too, very light on right to very dark on left, plus the nearly unavoidable glare spots (unless you wanted them). Challenge met. Focus seems pretty good. 6 Swash

Dude That Ain't the Cue Ball
by kris_photos

Comment:
Fun title! Eggball in the corner pocket! Focus seems sharp on the egg. Lighting doesn't really work for me, overall it seems dark, but the egg looks "right". The eightball is a bit hard to see, the background is just distracting, but you have a bit of a glare spot on the cue (meaning more light wouldn't be better). Too bad the chalk was right were it is, adds another slight distraction. 6 Swash

Timeless Elegance
by Brenna Kimi

Comment:
Interesting idea! I'm sorry, but I cannot tell what is being focused on, all seems somewhat out of focus. Overall image size is small and lacks detail. The flames are a nice touch. 5 Swash

All My Eggs.........
by TerryGee

Comment:
Very sharp focus on the egg basket (was that the point of this shot?). Eggs are soft blurs. 5 Swash

Whisked
by Freebie

Comment:
Focus and lighting seem really good. Challenge well met. While I see what you were going for with this angle, it just doesn't seem effective in this case, but it's better than the first score I gave it....score upgrade from 5 to 6. Swash

Intensified Jelly Eggs
by OneSweetSin

Comment:
It is shockingly bright! At first look, I thought the color intensity had affected the sharpness of this photo, but that's more surprise/optical illusion. The glare spots are a bit distracting, you might try softening your lighting. Challenge wise - it's a leap, but I'll go with it. 5 Swash

Egg 1
by EJ

Comment:
It's an egg! Focus seems a little off sharp, background is a littel too similarly colored, cropping seems overly tight and uneven, and the shadow is a bit grainy. 5 Swash

Green Egg
by PHOTOCHlX

Comment:
Interesting effect, but the egg seems to have suffered. The edges aren't very strong (focus?) and the background isn't to my liking (sorry). 5 Swash

Eggbert the Eggsplorer
by Geo_Griffin

Comment:
Very well done photo. Color and focus are very good. Few (other than I) quote the site rules for Other People's Art, but I do. This is OPA w/o much or any modification. I'm sorry, but I cannot give a high score to OPA, incorporate other items (even art/craft items), please. 5 Swash

HEY! What's this white thing???
by Doorskidder

Comment:
Cute shot. Seems on the pale side (you might want to try some color saturation, it's lega and does a world of good) The egg must be moving, so it's clarity isn't very high. Details of the sheet say the focus is very good, but with the cat legnthwise to the camera, much is out of focus. 5 Swash