...
by Reuben

Comment:
Where's the rest of the face. It's interesting, and there's nothing really wrong with this photo, per say, but I want to see more of the "people" or person in this case. I don't require the whole person, but I would have liked more...........................................
Photo 9 Creativity 9 People .5 (partial point for partial person) total 5 (takes your chances......)

Hats
by randy3y

Comment:
Cute idea. Color appears close to right, but why do I keep thinking over the top? Did you turn the color up? Try down a half step. Look at the orange lip on mom's hat, do you see a bright orange line at the shade line? Little girl's shirt almost washed out, it's tan, right?
Photo 8 Creativity 7 People 9 total 8

Fountain shadow girl
by daclozer

Comment:
Good color appeal, but the challenge was people. Your person is could have been substitued with a cardboard cutout. Great effect, but not for this challenge. Also, note the extranious lights in the background, the street light top center and the bar lights dead center distract from the shot. Move both you and subject to the right to avoid these lights.
Photo 9 Creativity 8 People 5 total 6 (weighted most heavily on the people challenge, sorry for the low grade)

Glass Houses
by mci

Comment:
VERY nice, there is alot of "interest" in this photo. My only problem is, I have consistantly downgraded others for small parts of people shots (mostly lame efforts), but this is soo good! You get an exception.
Photo 10 Creativity 10 People 8 (minus only 2 for very partial person) total 9 (all the other partials got 5 or less)

Best Friends
by karmat

Comment:
A bit dark and not enough contrast. Good focus, very sharp. Why not color? Photo 9 Creativity 7 People 9 total 8

Six Months
by Yellowpeep

Comment:
Technically, I see nothing wrong with this photo, but I do keep asking myself why sepia? But what do I know..... You cut off her thumb! Nit time: Not fond of body parts for people shots and yes, I know there's a baby inside, but I don't see him/her. Probably a personal problem.
Photo 9 Creativity 7 People (sorry) 6 total 7

Lennon in charge
by guybrowme

Comment:
Popular head cut off, please get all of the taller girl. This might have been better suited to portrait 480x640, instead of landscapte 640x480.
Photo 8 Creativity 6 People 9 total 7

frustration
by mnewman

Comment:
Not getting the shot you want? Almost great. You have some incedental motion at the top of the flash, doesn't help. The lamp in the background kinda appears to be growing out of the subject's head, not good. Too cluttered in lower left corner, too bare upper left corner. Try for more balance, grasshopper.
Photo 8 Creativity 6 People 9 (solid shot of the man) total 7

Uncertainty
by rumttugger

Comment:
Nice, well captured. Her right cheek and shirt collar are too washed out, left cheek and forehead much better. (No downgrade, but why black and white?)
Photo 7 Creativity 6 People 8 total 7

Fishing
by David Ey

Comment:
Is that bait? (I hope it's not the catch of the day!) Focus appears centered on man's forward arm. Motion might not be good in this case, try faster exposure. Man really stands out, like an overlay, but it's not. I like that you caught the sinker. Nice touch.
Photo 7 Creativity 7 People 7 total 7