Livin on the Edge
by boyte1

Comment:
VERY Red! Subject viewable, but barely, very dark and indistinct (maybe it moved). Photo 6 City 6 total 6

Toronto Wild Life
by Vitali

Comment:
Did you take this shot through a windows? I see a faint pattern in the sky, sort of like the windows of the building to the left. It's distracting, but not killer bad. Photo 9 City 9 total 9

Urban Atelier (School's Out)
by GeneralE

Comment:
Cute shot, mixed bag of shadowed and unshadowed subjects can be difficult, but you handled it well. Photo 9 City 9 total 9

Charlene on the MTA
by Kimbly

Comment:
Interesting blur/ghosting of subject, but difficult to view. Challenging shot. Photo 5 City 7 total 6

The News on the Street
by vonnie1956

Comment:
This is an interesting angle shot, but part of me wants to read the signs, no matter. Can't really say I'm thrilled with this shot, but there's nothing really bad/wrong with it. My guess is, it's just not my 'cup o tea'. Photo 8 City 7 total 7

AFTER 5
by freetime

Comment:
Sleepy town, how did you get this shot without anybody in it (I would have thought this was Before 5 AM!, not after 5 PM, as I am assuming your title..)
A Very Good Photo, but the sun setting above the hotel is hard to look at. I like the reflections in the windows. Wierd how pinstripping in digital comes out jagged and blurred, but that's the nature of this beastie (shades) Photo 8 City 6 total 7

Touring Chicago
by C3D

Comment:
Hancock building, right? (view at the top to the north is WONDERFUL!) (The church across the street is pretty nice, too) Sorry, but this is soooo fine, I don't see anything to critique for you. Maybe a smaller grouping, closer up (better detail per individual), but this is nice too. Photo 9 City 9 total 9

Inside Rural City Limits
by karmat

Comment:
Dark and a bit jaggy (overly blown up). A bit towards the edge of the Challenge, don't you think? (it's not even the cute type rodent, no cute points)
Photo 5 City 5 (bonus for what the heck +2) total 7

Alley McBar
by MikeKrueger

Comment:
I don't get the McBar reference in the title, is that the city name or the nearest street? As far as an alley shot goes, this is pretty much it. As for the question: "would I hang this in my house?", no, not really. Is it good enough to hang in a gallery, probably. Is the bright spot in the upper center of the shot the sun? (or haze?) No matter. Photo 7 City 7 total 7

Scratched.
by lisae

Comment:
Difficult image to view. Dark and grainy. Is the title referring to the caller or the booth? Photo 5 City 7 total 6