The wall (Pink Floyd)
by Parentx

Comment:
Challenge met, but....here's my thoughts on The Wall pictures. It's a story, more about the man's childhood than anything else and that time's effect on his personality. A mean old lady or scared child in front of this wall would make for a more complete story and stronger connection to the song. I connected to The Wall entries strongly at first, just because of the song. In my second viewing, the photo needs more, sorry, score downgrade from 7 to 6. Swash

Tulips from Amsterdam
by johnmk

Comment:
Neat picture. I wish I could say I recognize the song title, but I don't. Never fear, I don't score down for my lack of knowledge! The background is nice, but the lack of color compared to the foreground doesn't seem like a good thing to me. The tuplis/foreground is very, very nice. 7 Swash

Murder - The Crystal Method
by cq107

Comment:
A bit edgy for this crowd, don't you think? Very sharp, clear photo. The blood on the fingers seems more convincing than that on the blade (wonder why?) I don't know the song, but I will take your word for it, esp. since you bothered to include the band name (thanks, that helped!) 7 Swash

Raindrops keep falling on my head
by rascal

Comment:
Cute photo, what is the plant? (just curious) Neat rain drops. I don't see any rain falling (too chicken to get your camera wet! Just kidding!) It seems a little dark, maybe it's just the background. A few of the objects at the edges of the picture could be considered distracting, whatever, I don't mind too much. Really neat reflections in the rain drops!! 7 Swash

The Wall - Pink Floyd
by posthuman

Comment:
Nice, kinda interesting wall, but the song is sooo much more than stones. To me, this needs something more, an angry, bitter Mom or a little scared child, something along that line to complete the connection to the song. Sorry, but I don't care for the background. I'm sure you couldn't do much with that, but it distracts without adding value. I do sort of like the vine creaping up the wall, even though it has nothing to do with the song, well maybe......
Sorry, but upon further review, I'm dropping the score slightly on this one. From 7 to 6. Swash

En El Mar La Vida Es Más Sabrosa
by amonteforte

Comment:
Cute photo! Very good expressions. Sorry, I can't read spanish, but I'll take your word for that it meets the challenge, O.K? I think I would have liked to see the sun fall just a little more on their faces, but otherwise a really nice shot. (It turned out well anyway!) 7 Swash

These Boots Are Made For Walkin'
by vestanpance

Comment:
Yup! Very sharp photo. Since the boots are dirty/messy, I would think the background would need to be more solid (or vice versa). Challenge met. Seems to need stronger contrast. 7 Swash

See You Later, Aligator... (Bill Haley)
by miss parker

Comment:
Neat shot! Is this a baby? Something about the back of his head bothers me, but I can't describe what. Neat reflections. Challenge met. 7 Swash

"Needles and Pins"
by JMS

Comment:
Is that a show tune? Seem familiar, but I can't place it. Very good color! Very sharp! (Total NIT: somehow the single safety pin seems out of place, no score change for it) Interesting and nice to look at. 7 Swash (neat reflections, too)

Misty - Johnny Mathis
by bdshort

Comment:
(Tease - Isn't that Foggy?) Neat picture, great mystery in fog. Are you getting nasty comments about your frame? I like it, but maybe a little too dark. (No score effect either way!) 7 Swash