Cocaine, Eric Clapton
by tbarnby

Comment:
Very good, but only a fiver? (needs to be a Benny!) Well taken photo. Tiny suggestion - arrange the line in front (it is the finest, so adds more detail, then the bill and then the pile (it doesn't need the detail). Just a thought, ignore as you please. 7 Swash

Reflection
by TerryGee

Comment:
Neat picture. I can't honestly say I know what song you are referring to, but I will take your word for it. I really like the two petals pulled free, nice touch! Were I to guess, I don't think this picture would represent the song, but that wasn't the challenge, just it made it worth more points in my mind, you know a package deal.
7 Swash

Candle in the Wind
by Harz_Joerg

Comment:
Good representation of this song. I like the "spotlight" on the photo, nice touch, as is the flame blown to the left. Well thought out. I try to not compare photos, but since there were so many on this song, I thought I'd tell you, this one is THE best interpretation. (is that fair?) 8 Swash

Goodbye Norma Jeane
by bamaster

Comment:
Very appropriate to have the candle blown out. Nice smoke. Good thinking! Very clear, well taken, well framed shot. Nice background, not too gone, not too in the way. Too bad you couldn't manip the smoke into a shape like her face, that
would have been ultra cool! (but illegal) 7 Swash

Tie Me Kangaroo Down - Rolf Harris
by Martin

Comment:
Great tune! Neat picture (and I know you couldn't change this), but the 'roo and the dirt are so similarly colored, he blends in well. Very good focus/cropping. (Joke - it doesn't look like it is tied down at all!) 7 Swash

Yesterday.......
by rogerspaul

Comment:
Very good photo! Amazing that the goose is equally clear as the headstones!!!
I hate to pick nit with such wonderful work, but I think I don't care for the red building, upper left corner - a crop across the tops of the headstones works, well, sort of. The goose is amazing! Score upgrade from 7 to 8. Swash

I've Got You under My Skin
by 'Pong

Comment:
Cool in a way, but it just seems tooo close. What is that? Interesting, but difficult to look at. 6 Swash

Smile A Little Smile For Me
by SteveZ

Comment:
Well taken photo, but he doesn't look much like any Rosemarie that I remember. (joke, sort of) Songs are more than just titles, I had hoped the picture would reflect the song, not just the snippet that is the title. Very clear shot, it made me smile, too. 6 Swash

"Rose Tint My World"
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
I get it, but I'm not fully buying into it. Heavy manipulation has it's penalties in picture quality, this is no exception. Seems fuzzy due to the coloration (look at his knees). I don't know the song in question, but I'll take your word for it. (I'm not all knowing, really!) 6 Swash

(I Wanna Be) Your Underwear, Bryan Adams
by KimInNB

Comment:
Cute and lightly provocative! Nice shot. (flesh would have been nicer! Smile! Wink!) Very good color/focus. Interesting framing. Challenge well met.
7 Swash