900 Stars
by timmi

Comment:
Technical: fits the challenge. Exposure composition focus lighting all good- I really like the tight crop in this instance, but the few extra pixels allowed might have been nice!

Personal: Nice shot!

My vote: 7

Barber Shop Snowman
by dr rick

Comment:
Technical: definitely fits the challenge! Exposure composition focus lighting all good.

Personal: Funny, he looks like a cross between a snow man and some sort of superhero!! :-)

My vote: 7

Christmas Dog ?
by sjcherian

Comment:
Technical: fits the challenge. Exposure looks relatively good. Composition is interesting. Focus looks like it's soft on the subject. Lighting good.

Personal: An interesting shot but the lack of sharpness bugs me.

My vote: 4

Noel
by bobgaither

Comment:
Technical: fits the challenge. Exposure composition focus lighting all good.

Personal: Yep! Definitely fits! Though it occurs to me if it's on one of those streets where everybody does this, it actually is pretty spectacular!

My vote: 10

Wonderfully Tacky
by rich

Comment:
Technical: Bang on the challenge! Exposure composition focus lighting all excellent!

Personal: Perfect for the theme!

My vote: 10

Tacky but Tasty
by Harz_Joerg

Comment:
Technical: fits the challenge well! Exposure composition focus lighting all excellent!

Personal: What a great shot! Extremely creative!!

My vote: 10

Eat Drink and Be Merry!
by lizzyc3

Comment:
Technical: fits the challenge well. Exposure composition focus lighting all very interesting. I like the spotlighted effect, but it looks a little too hot on the lower right.

Personal: This took a lot of creativity- nicely done!!

My vote: 9

... atop the tree sat a beautiful angel
by jen1979

Comment:
Technical: fits the challenge- definitely tacky. Exposure- looks flashed, which is rarely attractive. Composition is a little too tight and the picture frame in the background doesn't add to the photo- turning the angel so that a blank wall was behind it might have helped along with using a long exposure instead of flash. Focus okay.

Personal: Gerat for theme, not my favorite technically.

My vote: 5

Old Fashion in Fashion Centre!!!
by Reza1968

Comment:
Technical: Sorry, but for me this doesn't fit the challenge- I don't think it's tacky I think it's kinda nice! Perhaps full color would have made it look tackier. Exposure composition focus lighting all excellent.

Personal: I think this is a lovely photo, the silvery tones make it look quite elegant to me.

My vote: 6

Merry Christmas with NO MONEY DOWN!!!
by dsa157

Comment:
Technical: fits the challenge well! Exposure composition focus lighting all great.

Personal: Funny. Great for the challenge!

My vote: 9