Silence Interrupted
by Paul

Comment:
Your idea is good and fits the title. The shot is simple but quite effective to convey the idea behind your title but in itself does not convey a feeling of silence. Whilst the pin is positioned perfectly in the frame there is too much empty space at the bottom and on the right and the image would benefit if cropped a little tighter. Maybe an inch and a half of the bottom and off the right hand side. 4

Strangers in a park
by avkuvalekar

Comment:
Pretty glum looking people and quite a lot of litter all over the ground. I'm sure they are silent as they aren't talking to each other but the image as a whole does not convey a strong feeling of silence to me. As for the composition....you chopped the guys legs off and the photo would be much improved if you had stood a bit further back. Also you cropped a bit to close to the tops of their heads. 4

Red Silence
by JaimeVinas

Comment:
So many entries that show a person with a finger pressed to their lips. I know it's meant to imply "Quiet or Be silent" but the image does just not convey a feeling of "Silence" to me. 5

Idle Barn
by npasel

Comment:
Looks quite idle and silent indeed. Also looks a bit out of focus and a tad unsharp. 4

Censored
by Haneck

Comment:
So many "tape over the mouth" images in this challenge. I have lost count.
It just does not evoke the feeling of "Silence" to me. The title also says nothing to me. This to me says "Silenced" but not "Silence" 5

Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!
by rmezzo

Comment:
So many entries that show a person with a finger pressed to their lips. I know it's meant to imply "Quiet or Be silent" but the image does just not convey a feeling of "Silence" to me. 5

Duct Tape: For Peace of Mind
by Camabs

Comment:
So many "duct tape over the mouth" images in this challenge. I have lost count.
It just does not really evoke the feeling of "Silence" for me. This to me says "Silenced" but not "Silence" 5

Shhhhhhhhhhhhh
by aKiwi

Comment:
So many entries that show a person with a finger pressed to their lips. I know it's meant to imply "Quiet or Be silent" but the image does just not convey a feeling of "Silence" to me. 5

Listen Carefully...
by mileskea

Comment:
Ok...I am but I hear nothing...only silence as all the pins have dropped already. But that's what we want to convey isn't it? Silence. So in that respect this image succeeds but it does not impart to me the feeling of silence. What it also doesn't do for me is that it does not hold my attention and all I see are 5 pins of which 3 have part of them cut off by the frame. Also there is too much empty blue space at the top. 4

The Silent
by MAK

Comment:
The close-up of this statue does not really convey a strong feeling of silence to me. Nicely photographed though with good dof, tectures and tones. 5