Maternal bond
by ace flyman

Comment:
Great to capture the moment of birth, but not a photo for this challenge. Itis a snapshot to record a moment, not a photograph for the challenge or wider distribution. Does not meet the challenge for me. Just my thoughts, others may see it differently

Domo Arigato, Mr. Roboto
by Lonz

Comment:
Great effect with the basic composition. The angle of the numbers makes this photo, as well and the lighting applied.

There are languages, then there are languages
by retiredPhil

Comment:
The idea of this is good, however the composition looks messy. The crap and angle shot at also do not help the effect

A Universal Language
by isonaj

Comment:
Music is a Universal language that doesn't matter if you understand the words or not. Great take on the challenge topic for this.

Angle is great, depth of field is great. Lighting seems to be the problem here. It is difficult to get the light right to show enough detail and not have either under or overexposed areas. The lighting is reasonable, but did need to be a bit better to get the top socres

Old Oil Lamp
by drewhosick

Comment:
Nice, works well. Composition is great. Well done

The old pickup truck.
by see

Comment:
I know what you were trying to achieve with the processing, but it means the cart no longer stands out from the background, and therefore the impact is lost

1940s News Source
by Balko

Comment:
Love the processing of this, love the image. I think everything you have left here has its place, even the cropped out picture. The light is good, it all works.........

the last of the sheppards
by lenia

Comment:
A very flat image, but that is the look that I think you were going for, and it suits the type of image and what you are trying to say here, so it works. She is a little too centred for me. I feel you needed to crop out the right hand side, have her sitting on the third line, the sheep than through the picture, with some space to the left showing where she is walking towards. Shooting further along the path (ie captureing further to the left) could have reqally made a massive difference here, and got you a really good score.

PHOTOGRAPHY BEFORE COMPUTERS
by hjl

Comment:
Now, I like the idea, I like the Red Light, the books, the Film. Maybe they could have been arranged in a more interesting way though, some more film spread around or something just to give this a little extra kick. This is especially the case as you can't use colour to give it this.....

Former Child Star - Ricky Schroeder
by love

Comment:
Is it????
For this type of photo, which is an opportunist shot, and not something set up, you have done well. The light is pretty good (a few minor issues) but its not like you are in a studio. Same with the person in the bg as well.
Good opportunist shot