World's Best Wheat
by dunces

Comment:
2 problems I have with the photo, first is the guy in it, he takes over the picture rather than it being the 'wheat', second is the green twine on the wheat itself, I know you can't control it, but if you could, removing it would really help the photo.

Inbetween
by Jovi

Comment:
Picture seems to be a bit over neatimaged/smoothed.

Extraordinary Sacrifice
by digistoune

Comment:
I really really want to like this photo. This truly does meet the extraordinary part of the challenge. The subject is exceptional, however in saying this, the actual layout leaves a little to be desired. The purple heart seems to not be as brilliant a purple as it should be. Include the entire ribbon in the picture and not crop a piece of it off to the left. Probably my biggest problem in looking at the picture is the white space to the top right. I would have almost liked to see the reflection of the flag covering the entire photo (or at least would like to see if it would make a difference or not)

Extraordinary Color
by Digichrome

Comment:
I generally like water drops on flowers, but the one on the petal is very distracting to me. The DOF (IMO) being on the middle of the petals does not contain enough interest (except for the water drop which takes away from the image), that I would have liked to see it a little deeper to include at least the smaller petals of the same color.

Vintage
by cbeller

Comment:
The light is just too overpowering on the picture, making it the total focus to the detriment of the fine automobile that it is attached to.

Large Leaves!
by aKiwi

Comment:
By using the desaturation, it has caused the tops of the leaves to look blown out, which makes me look at what is apparently white space instead of seeing the focus on the leaves themselves.

Nanners...the new forbidden fruit
by BigZenDragon

Comment:
This would be really good, but one nitpick, the nose piercing does not have enough detail to make it part of the picture, and thus I'm wondering about the 'booger' that was left on the side of the nose after a wipe, and is incongruous to the clarity and beauty of the rest of the photo. Everything else is fantastic in the photo.

Banana Farmer
by leaf

Comment:
My mind just does not picture this gentleman as a banana farmer, but I could be wrong.

The Great Banini
by jperez1690

Comment:
As a photo, this is interesting, I hope it gets validated. Hope you post how you did it after the voting. The hole in the pepper is distracting to me, I thing would have been stronger with just the banana and the cantalope.

Split
by KaDi

Comment:
Now, most people peel their bananas before making the banana split.