Sunset At The River Of Hammer And Steel
by Mundi

Comment:
I find this one hard to critique, but I really like it. well thought out idea and execution. I wish the black tones were a bit darker, but you did a great job with this one.

Solder
by ScottK

Comment:
my favorite in the challenge. great colors. I like the shape and texture of the solder blob and the long exposure, blurring the steam.

Hibernation
by Skamal

Comment:
nice color and exposure except for that white object in the lower left and the key. why not review and reshoot in the future to remove those kinds of distractions.

City Driver Parking In Suburbia
by GolferDDS

Comment:
funny. great idea.

The Garage - Men's Last Dominium
by byshen

Comment:
great lighting. very moody. although no guy's shelves are that well organized...

Time for an oil change
by tomlewis1980

Comment:
nice textures. your shadows could have been reduced a bit better- they still seem a little hard edged to me.

10 Inch Wrench
by keone

Comment:
this simple object study is made more interesting by the textured background you chose.

light bender...
by theodor38

Comment:
great lighting, great shadows, great composition. I really like how the shadows are just created from your fingers.

Palidan
by RHoldenSr

Comment:
this is a cool profile of you with your hat, but rather than having the entire face in shadow, I think it might have been more effective to have directed lighting where you had shadow over your eyes, for example, but the rest of the portrait was well lit. As it is, it looks more like a badly underexposed shot than an intentional effect.

My Inspiration
by goinskiing

Comment:
the head and hand in thoughtful repose looks great but the cheesy bulb above the head spoils the shot for me. It looks like it was hurriedly cut and pasted into the image.