Pele
by thegrandwazoo

Comment:
Crisp, clever. Good thought process. 8

The falls at Goodwins Mills
by tjbel05

Comment:
Nice shot and good luck. Only criticism I have is that it might have been more impressive if the river actually flowed from corner to corner through the image. 9

Water: and the sky opened::::
by veggie

Comment:
Would have like to see the child worked on to bring out some more detail in the front. It appears a bit dark and loses some of the emotion created in the shot.

Of This Earth
by escapetooz

Comment:
Great thought process in this one. I like everything about this one. I like the way the sunset/rise draws you into the model, and the pose, to me works and blends well with the overall feel of the image. 10 and Good Luck

"I've seen fire and I've seen rain"
by fredahenry

Comment:
Nice 9

Reflections of Narnia
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Not sure what Narnia has to do with the Four Elements and not sure why you went for this title. Perhaps a more fitting title would do the image more justice in this challenge. It is an impressive image and well processed, I just fear that some might score your image lower due to the lack of relevance to the challenge category. 9

Summer Evening by the River
by MaryO

Comment:
I imagine the full size image would look fantastic. I think that you have lost some of the brilliance of this in the resizing, which does not deserve lowering your score. 9 for me.

Harnessing Wind and Water
by Bruce_the_Robert

Comment:
A bit more contrast would make this image POP. Nice shot, just lacks the pop it could have for me. Well done. 7

Shapely
by Brin

Comment:
Voted on 36 Percent of photos so far and this is my favourite image by a long shot so far. 10 IMO

furrows
by sidpixel

Comment:
Nice work. For a Basic Editing Challenge, the only thing that I could comment on for the downside of this image is the composition. Perhaps symmetry would have made this slightly better, but isn't worth voting lower on. 10