Where's Who?
by pahl

Comment:
This has become rather flat - I don't get much sense of depth from this lighting - everything's pretty bright and full on, rather than using a graduation of shading across the set-up.

X Marks the Spot
by HOOlovesdrums

Comment:
The apprach feels a little obvious - though it is well done, and that light ought to add more impact than it actually has. I wonder if a touch more control would be needed, or greater contrast between the lit and 'unlit' areas - your 'x' doesn't register very strongly for me.

Yes, Waldo Is Here, Out In The Back 40!
by Gallatin

Comment:
I like this - despite a number of things that one ought not to like - the crazy shadow across the horse, the confusion with the horse's head being in front of the tree; but there's a certain mad remote quality to it that appeals to me.

I'm looking for Reindeer moss.......
by Richie23

Comment:
Panoramic format shots are always difficult on this site - inevitably, they appear so constrained by the resolution restrictions. I like this, though I would have thought about positioning the deer and the face more evenly relative to the frame, perhaps. It works for me though - if only it could be a little larger :-(

Matrix: The Cold Blue Glow of Reality (tribute to e301's image 21678)
by ahaze

Comment:
Whoa.

To quote a , er, film.

This has the look of a 5x7 or even 4x6 torn photo - mine was 11x8 and thus getting the line of the tear much easier (ah, the voice of expertise). You've certainly got the colour balance of the top image - that's an important element to me - but your lower is a bit confused. Very flattering to be imitated however.

Increased Prospects - image 61751
by spectre013

Comment:
Immediately referencible (?), but different, and well done. the colours lack some punch I think - for this kind of set-up thing shouldn't you want big vibrant shades? The greens and yellows look a bit washed out to me.

Ho Ho Ho, Merry Christmas!
by Konador

Comment:
Cleaner and neater than the original, I would say. Unfortunately, I don't see that you've moved things on much from what was never a particular favourite of mine anyhow. Technically, it's beautifully done, absolutely flawless I would say. It still elicits a big 'so what?' from me though.

Flirtaceous (Color Studio Portrait)
by GolferDDS

Comment:
Oh man, funniest shot in the bunch. Love this - so very nearly offensive, nd just so funny. Good luck.

Tribute to Smokeditor
by Sonda

Comment:
Moody, sexy, wonderfully lit and shot. Almost an exact copy, except for the even more moody lighting.

A Terrifying Thai Treat
by dsb_mac

Comment:
Good light, good set-up; hasn't quite the hyper-designer look of the original, which was what to my mind gave it it's impact. The bug, though, looks no more appetising :-)