hold my beer and watch this...(432912)
by photokariangel

Comment:
excellent photograph but unfortunately it is not even slightly similar to image 432912:


In this case you did not make a favor to yourself by putting the image number in the title.

Sun Rise by romi
by jdannels

Comment:
beautiful image

When I first saw this image I thought "wow, great image, what a big mistake not to include a reference to the original image in the title"

It took me a while to find romi's Sun Rise image:


Then I understood why you did not make any explicit reference to it....the concept has been completely changed which, unfortunately, means this image is a DNMC to me.

If voters do not realize that, this photo could end up in the front page or at least in the top 5.

Window to the Soul
by bobonacus

Comment:
It does meet the challenge



I think you made a mistake by not putting the image number in the title because only after seeing the original it is possible to really appreciate this photo, otherwise the unapealing texture of te skin kind of bothers too much (but then I realized the original has the same kind of texture which gives additional value to this image).

Excellent execution

Pup Star (Glasses challenge, 758239)
by tnun

Comment:
it does meet the challenge
not crazy about the lighting here

EEEEKKK!!!ABUG!!! ( "Childhood Without Children" Challenge)
by androgeus

Comment:

yeah insects in both cases, and an excellent capture
but this is not a dragon fly and imho there are too many diferences in the concept/subject.

One Fit Squirrel
by Kelli

Comment:
i could not find the image you are trying to remake
it looks dark and blurry though

From "Kitchen Ware" Challenge April, 2007 (Artist -- TJinGuy)
by phylsy7

Comment:
it does meet the challenge
nice try

Rose for my "Valentine" Inspired by boricuaballer 747615
by Crafty

Comment:
it does meet the challenge
nice try.

Lines Are Everywhere - Puzzle Macro II
by essay

Comment:
it does meet the challenge
good execution

Fur (Textures V)
by MaryO

Comment:
lovely dof, excellent execution....top 5 pick.