Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment:
Neil, for me this had several strikes against it. First, I felt inundated by sunsets in this challenge, so this suffered in comparison. Second, if my score is hovering between two numbers, and I see a letterbox frame, I'll probably go with the lower number, because I think a letterbox frame adds a quality that isn't inherent to the photo. (I realize that may be unfair, but it's my own personal pet peeve lately). Most important, though, as a result of processing I thought this ended up sort of "muddy." I agree with Ken that the print version looks more realistic and may I add sharper.

Originally posted by oldbimmercoupe: call me a conspiracy nut, but I also detect an anti-NYC bias here.

Oh yeah, there's that, too. I *know* that's why my entry bombed. ;-)

Hidden smile
by WalesP

Comment:
I thought this was a self-portrait by Jutilda! Lighting is strong, but a "semi-candid snap?" Hardly.

"The One Who Brings the Offer, He is the Traitor." -- "The Dogfather Part 1", Ac
by Jammur

Comment:

Originally posted by Jammur: "The One Who Brings the Offer, He is the Traitor." -- "The Dogfather Part 1", Act 4, Scene 1 The old hound reminded me so much of Abe Vigoda in the cemetery scene, whispering to Al Pacino. But I wasn't sure about setting a record for the longest title.

You are one wacky dude! :-D

Blue Eyes
by CindyG

Comment:
Bright, colorful, happy... coulda/shoulda scored better.

FYI, you can always add Photographers Comments - there should be a link for you at the bottom of the "Photograph Information" box that says "Edit the Details of the Image."

Don't Tread on Me
by Jason_Cross

Comment:
Sorry for the DQ -- I'd never have guessed it's an "assemblage" -- I still like it! :-)

MY PEANUT
by toddhead

Comment:
She's way too pretty for you. :-D

I was one of your 6-votes, and yeah, it looks pretty soft on my monitor. I know what you mean about competing monitors, though. I have the same work/home dichotomy.

Cobus, My Son.
by docpjv

Comment:
This is a striking portrait, but needed more light. I think you processed the eyes to make them stand out more but the result is a bit unnatural. I am struck by the ruggedness of his face contrasting with the softness of the knit sweater with the pink strip.

Peter, your story makes me sad. There is a deep, soulful look about this man. I'm sorry for your troubles.

Candid Moment
by Brad

Comment:
Underrated. Portraits seem to be a tough sell!

Chaozhou (Chinese) Opera Singer
by Tiberius

Comment:
Strong portrait, very colorful. No offense to the model, but something made me suspect this was a boy. Evidently I've been living in New York City too long.

Meteor
by Meowgli

Comment:
Congrats on doing so well with your first entry.