...at the Station
by MikeO

Comment:
The B&W conversion here is exceptional. The lighting on the couple helps to emphasize that they are the main "stationary" subjects of this image. I gave this a 9 because it is superb.

Going nowhere fast
by DJWoodward

Comment:
I rated this image a 9, as I really think you nailed the composition and framing of this image. I even like the brightness of the roof, as it helps show just how exposed to the elements this old truck really is. I agree with glad2badad regarding the contrast and levels. Hope my first challenge entry is as good as this image.

Worn by Time
by justin_hewlett

Comment:
I didn't comment on this image during the challenge because I thought it would score much higher and receive a lot of positive feedback. This is an image I would be very happy to call one of my own. You took a very stationary object and presented its character in a very dynamic manner. The lighting is perfect and provides a definite focal point imho. I gave this a 9.

Arlington on the Beach
by dfriedland

Comment:
I didn't comment on this image during the challenge because I thought it would score much higher and receive a lot of positive feedback. I really like the flow of this image. The only improvement would be to include a bit more of the cross front and center, as the blue flag tends to make this a focal point for this image.

Rovinj
by gregaR

Comment:
The sky in this image is very lovely to look at. However, the buildings have a little too much detail and compete with the sky for the viewer's attention. If you decrease the detail in the building using levels or curves, the lines of the building silhouette will naturally lead the viewer's eyes to the wonderful sunset and the boats in the water.

My perspective
by Snaethor

Comment:
The interaction between the sky, the towers and the power lines is very effective and well done. The person on the left really doesn't add to the composition and actually causes a distraction, drawing the viewer's eyes away from the strongest element in the composition.

over the river and through the woods
by fordmanf1

Comment:
I like the perspective you took of this bridge but the overall green hue is a bit overwhelming. You might want to consider changing this to a b&w image and play with the contrast a little bit. This image has so much potential.

Light and Shadows
by pinbokeshatta

Comment:
The colors in this image are wonderful and the silhouette is nicely done. However, the wire and towers above the bridge really hurt this image and the angle of the left tower looks a little odd. If you clone these items out after the challenge, this could be a very powerful image.

A Perspective on Life: Bloom Where You are Planted
by karmat

Comment:
I really like the positioning of the seed in this image. The triangle in the lower right corner helps the composition tremendously. I would have liked to have seen the seed completely in focus. Having three out of focus areas (foreground, background, and part of the main subject) makes the viewer work to find the focal point of the image. You may want to consider cropping out the whiteish-blue area in the top right corner. It has a tendency to draw the viewers attention away from the main subject of the image (You could also clone it out after the challenge).

Under the Texan Sun
by elsapo

Comment:
From yout title I know that the sun is an important part of this composition to you; however, cropping it out may allow you to balance the saturation and contrast better to help make the colors of the butterfly pop. You may also want to consider cropping this into a horizontal image, as the negative space to the right of the butterfly is add more to the image than the space above the butterfly.