Blackness covering emptiness
by ajschel

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club!
Very nice photograph! very very creative and very well thought out.
You did well!
a few things i see as an artist, and, remember, we all see things thru different eyes, so this is not to be taken to heart, just suggestions you may or may not agree with, that is ok!
First, i find there is to much empty space in between the black on the bottom right, to the darkness at upper part, it does not give me the feeling it is taking over, instead i feel the lighter color is taking over, but still well thought out.
I wonder, had you stood back further and left more of the darker pavement in the picture, and a bit different angle, if you would lead me to feel the blackness is taking over.I also wonder if you left out the tall skyscraper and just left the dark trees on the other side, what that would do and leave less sky? just thingsthat are popping out at me that i see, that may be a bit different than you.
Still i commend you on this! Congrats on a photo well thought out and executed.
Christine
Aka sarnewfie.

Grand Opening
by Bugzeye

Comment:
OMG i have a shot very samiliar to this! :) nice job!

All forgotten
by terje

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club.
What is there not to like about this gorgous, well thought out photograph?
I have pondered on this one a lot, and , all i have is praise for this, it belongs in a frame on someone`s wall!
You did a wonderful job on this lovely composition, with your own touch.
The slow shutterspeed makes the water apear glasslike, though myself, i prefer to see things natural, without the silk look, it still is art and not to be faulted.
The colors in the sky are beautiful and add depth to this, i love the rocks in the foreground.
Thank you for sharing, and continued success is wished upon you!

cattail_setup_4069_copy.jpg
by 2mccs

Comment:
WOW!!!!
this is soooo creative, you really used everything you had for this one, and, it turned out gorgous!

Orbs - redux
by Tom_Robbrecht

Comment:
Very impressive! this image is pleasing to the eye with wonderful color and framing, love the angle, love the reflection and the focus is wonderful.

pink walkway
by gurlwithapen

Comment:
WOW this is way cool! i love it.
there are different things you can do with this, for instance to add more walled in feeling, you can crop down from the top, a good inch , and, up from the bottom about an inch, it adds more height and walled in feeling, really nice find on your part and very nicely framed and presented.

Multi-faceted
by H700256

Comment:
This is very beautiful and extremly challenging, the lighting is nice but could be better to give you more depth to your red glass surrounding the white beauty! i think if you had more definition it would give more depth and more character to the white glass that is the star.
the lighting in the front is almost to much, yet at the top of the pic is quite dark. Not to offend as still this is quite a nice shot.
thank you for sharing.

Beach Treasure
by KarenNfld

Comment:
This is quite creative and very well framed cept for two things, i think you could afford to crop down a bit from the top, and a bit from the bottom, some say the blur at the bottom is a good thing, others say it is not, i for one find it useful in some instances, but this one, i think would be much better without that much blur down below, the eye is not going right to the treasure when this loads due to so much at the top.
this still is very well composed! thanx for sharing.

Glass Float
by red_gecko

Comment:
this is a beautiful image, it has a wonderful crisp clear focus, and it is in good lighting, i really love the closeup, would like to see a bit more creativity though with this.
that is just me and it is an individual comment, not meant to offend. you still did a lovely job on this one.

Beaten Path
by justin_hewlett

Comment:
very nice work on this one, it is well chosen for the challenge, well framed with good focus and wonderful sepia color~ thanx for sharing.