Aero X
by redmoon

Comment:
I really like the angle and the complete absence of color (which was how I interpreted the challenge). 9

Through the peephole
by paulw

Comment:
I'm not sure why I like this, but I do. And it meets the challenge (to me) better than most. 9

I came back to this after voting on all the entries. The only thing I could think to improve this is to maybe have it a little more off-center (with the window a little more to the left). Still, this is one of my favorites in this challenge... I'm going to bump it to a 10.

Triumph
by dahved

Comment:
To me, this challenge was about shooting a color photo that fooled the viewer into thinking it was B&W. Your shot was one of the few that succeeded... even so much as to make me wonder if you helped it with a little desaturation. Well done. 9

Desert tree
by avb

Comment:
I feel this meets the challenge as I interpreted it. Many did not. If you printed (in color) and framed your photo, most people would think it was taken in B&W. Your photo is definitely in my top 10.

Progress to Bloom
by philup

Comment:
Wow... I'm surprised this one placed so low. I really liked it and thought it fit the challenge. I gave you a 9.

BW Beach
by rook

Comment:
I like the picture a lot, but the frame is a bit large in my opinion. I still feel this is one of the more interesting photos in this challenge. 9

Pen to Paper
by H700256

Comment:
I like the image... but the jagged edges were too distracting.

Bloody Mary! Bloody Mary! Bloody Mary!
by DrAchoo

Comment:
My favorite in this challenge. 10