Layers
by Fotowereld

Comment:
I'm sure you are going to receive a lot of comments concerning the attractiveness of the image. There is certainly a good amount of texture in the image. I find the choice to have a lot of negative black space at the top and the foot to be cropped an interesting one, but it doesnt really do much for me personally. I'm sure it would be considered an artistic shot but it doesnt have much of an impact on me.

Living Statue
by Gracious

Comment:
It's an interesting shot but I find my interest is on his face and so find the vast amount of shirt to be a little excessive. If getting closer or cropping tighter around the face wasnt an option then at least cropping off some of the bottom may have helped.

B&W
by Long

Comment:
It's a good idea and you have various shapes and textures but there are a few technical issues that let the image down. The highlight on the metal frame is blown, and there are some distracting light reflections on the bottle too. The sheet the items are on is ruffled near the apple and that is a little distracting also. Overall the image is a little static.

Hard day
by Bullpup

Comment:
I find my personal interpretation of this image interesting and am curious to see if that was the intended message or not. The drink has bad connotations for me as in s/he has been driven to alchol as a result of the job, but the cigar has a celebratory feel or one of relaxation. There is a clear duality present in the image. Photographically it looks good, but the placement of the cigar looks a little odd.

October
by Kavey

Comment:
I like the shape that the leaves make and the blend of colors is also good. The white background is nicely white but the leaves almost feel a little too isolated and just floating there. It certainly conveys the chosen month well.

November
by vtruan

Comment:
The scene itself is wonderful and has near, middle and far elements. The placement of the tree is good and the curve of the land almost mirrors the curve of the mountain. It looks like it was shot under a fairly harsh light so the lighting seems a little flat. The quality doesnt look too good as there is some noise in the blues and either it has been oversharpened, too much contrast, or just the camera's resolution.

November - First Snow
by Gauti

Comment:
It's an interesting shot but I'm not sure what to say about it. I like the light dusting of snow on the sculpture - the white contrasts nicely with the black and it is almost like it is adding accents to the curves and details. The mountain backdrop is stunning and works well to lead the eye down to the horizon, although that appears to be slightly tilted. The muted colors except for the splash of yellow near the horizon line adds to the chilly feel of the shot.

Falling in November
by Rando D300

Comment:
Wonderful lighting and depth of field! S/he just pops out of the shot. The colors are great and the white dog contrasts nicely with them. The leaf in action and the dog watching carefully is a wonderful interaction. The catchlight in the eye is great too. Only thing I'm not sure about is the composition. The cropped out feet makes it feel a little odd. Having the entire legs/feet in or even the entire dog would be good or else cropping out the legs but I cant decide if that causes it to lose some dynamics or not. Even so, it's a fun, well-shot image!

July
by karmat

Comment:
It's a good shot but feels fairly static. You have some high-flying fast jets seemingly suspended in mid air in the middle of the shot. Dont get me wrong, I've seen shots like this a lot and I'm sure a shot like this would appear in a calendar but it's not very compositionally interesting even though their manoeuver is certainly exciting to watch.

Betty Crocker's February
by toddhead

Comment:
A good white color without losing detail in the plate, which is very cute. The red of the sauce blends well with the white and adds a nice color contrast. The depth of field is good, the theme of hearts is good and appropriate for February. Composition is good too. Good image!