The Red Bike
by jagar

Comment:
Very nice! A unique take on the challenge. Quite some guts to take a B/W shot and title it "The RED Bike" :)
Would've been better without the cable lock on the bike I think - lol

Harmonic Cheers
by william88

Comment:
Wow! I can't figure out how in the world you achieved this!! Amazing!
Love the lighting, the seamless background, the colors, the crispness, the improbability of it all. Very well done.

Fine Tawny Port
by Brin

Comment:
Such beautiful decanter and goblets! And shot in such wonderful soft backlight! Love the muted colors - fabulous shot!

Red
by Structor

Comment:
Nice idea, Good lighting, Seamless background - well done.

The inner layer of glasses was unnecessary I think - Given the angle of the shot, they are not easily distinguishable, and are just confusing the clean lines of the outer layer of glasses.
The reflection is double-layered and jarring. I'm guessing you used a glass mirror instead of plastic/plexi?

Lite wine
by Silent-Shooter

Comment:
Nicely done! I'm guessing Frozen/Jello in the glass, stuck to the table and inverted? Nice idea well executed. Great lighting and a funny title :)
The only thing keeping this from being perfect is that the table curve is not symmetric around the wine glass.

LADYBUG RED: Put Some Color In Your Life
by nickyb

Comment:
Nicely done! I can see this as a printed advertisement - the caption suits it perfectly as well.

Waiter!
by hesitant

Comment:
lol - nice title to go with a wonderful pic. I can almost hear the yell - "Waaaiiiiteeeerrrrrr!!!"
Very nicely lit stop motion shot. Love the pattern of the wine that escaped.

The border is not my cup of tea though - very distracting.

Red Leads the Way.
by Jon_H

Comment:
Good idea. Nice soft lighting to go with it.
The light green background is probably not the best idea - doesn't make the wine look appetizing. A warm, subtle color or black might've done a better job I think.

Cheers
by Kelli

Comment:
Love the goblets!
However, the colorful background is very distracting and doesn't add much to the scene - it just competes for attention.
Also, am not sure if this a HDR, but that lack of shadows makes the dimples on the glass look flat and cheap. Usually, such texture benefits from non-uniform lighting and the shadows it casts.

Wine Drop
by davidw

Comment:
Hope you aren't getting too hammered on the scoring.
As I found out the hard way, DPC considers drop shots a cliche, and scores them down quite a bit. To fare well with drop shots here, the quality has to be extraordinary. Here's a shot that's done well for instance (just to give you an idea):