Tribute to jagar's entry in the "Photo Tutorial" challenge
by AllenP

Comment:
Excellent shot for itself, obviously not very close to John's shot (subject aside, in your shot: POV higher and more frontal, cool toning, more sharpening, more detail in the shadows, deeper DOF)

The Secret Self/Secret Self Portrait challenge
by snaffles

Comment:
Well done in terms of lighting and composition, not so much in terms of model and props. Using Samantha or a Barbie doll as a model makes a huge difference :)

fantasia by Gordon http://www.dpchallenge.com/image.php?IMAGE_ID=55938
by Giles

Comment:
Obvious, even without the title, of which shot this is a remake. Composition is almost spot on, but you didn't achieve what the original had: implying fast motion without having the brush blurred - not saying your brush is blurred, it's just that the combination of brush and light looks more natural - must be the tilted view and a longer exposure with more than one light streak.

Tribute to Squeak (Pet Portrait III)
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Almost as close as it gets, considered this is not Squeak. Only DOF in Yanko's image was deeper (nose was fully in focus, neck almost).

Open Cup Mushroom / e301
by hajeka

Comment:
Good shot, but not as close to the original as I wished for, seems to be a different species of mushroom. Also crop is closer and the shallow DOF leads to a lack in detail, which is the essence of e301's shot

Freedom
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
Easily recognizable, but not as good as the original, especially in terms of exposure ad POV

Eight Ball — Corner Pocket
by GeneralE

Comment:
A good shot, you achieved to recreate the exact mood. However, DOF and composition are quite different as your lens was too wide.

Reprise, reprise, reprise
by BrennanOB

Comment:
Thanks for choosing my image, I'm flattered :)

Very well done in terms of lighting and overall mood, could just be a tad brighter.
Missing border might be a matter of taste, but I wonder why you flipped the subject?
Also looks like you used a bit much denoising.

At Your Service for Decades Redux - A tribute to Gyaban
by Samantha_T

Comment:
Excellent work, even more appealing than the original (at least for male viewers) only nitpick would be the color of background.

Liquid Pearls
by giantmike

Comment:
Very good attempt, though the lighting is different the composition is almost the same