At the Corner of Charles and Maple
by karmat

Comment:
Was it the storm that took the tree down that took down the sign? My biggest complaint is the shade on the sign that says "Maple". Can't read it. May move a little and you could get a little more light on it. Other wise it's a fantastic photo and definitely meets the challenge. I'll still give it a 7.

Stop
by rj324

Comment:
It's cropped too closely for me to see much unique about this sign. It might be right at the edge of the woods and the road ends there, but I can't tell from the photo. Needs to be pulled back from showing some of the surroundings for me to see what is unique here. The sign is also fuzzy around the edges. Need better focus. It's a 4 from me.

No cruising till 6:00 a.m.
by justine

Comment:
Great photo and really hard to understand sign. They're both a 9 form me. Good cropping and focus. Like the composition. Nice setting. Really nice photo.

Tag! You're it.
by Dez

Comment:
I sure wouldn't know what to do here. I'd give way to everyone I guess and not move until I was the last one left. Love the angle you took it at. That adds at least 2 to 3 more points. Good focus and crop. Real nice job. It's a 8 from me.

Modern Romance
by magnetic9999

Comment:
Can't quite figure this one out. The texture of the red rose looks to be over sharpened. The rest appears to almost jump off the photo as being real, but show no signs of sharpening. Is that the normal texture of that particular rose? The rest of the photo looks like I can reach out and touch the flower. That's an awesome 10 for that. Just don't know about the red one.

Heavenly
by Turbotech

Comment:
AWESOME photo. Love the light. Sorry about the allergy. Beautiful combination of colors. Love the cup and saucer and the setting. Great job. Should be in there. It's get my 10.

Alright, Who's Got the Hot Milk?!!
by Antithesis

Comment:
Looks like a baptism we did in Khazaksthan in 50 degree temperature. This must be something simular to be dressed this way on an obviously cold day. Great photo of the people. Love the colors, the focus, the cropping the composition, but wouldn't know it was about milk without the title. I believe to fit the challenge it must show the challenge without the title. The best I could give it would be a 4.

Contradiction
by mliborio

Comment:
Good idea just needs better execution. Would have come across better if you couldn't see the seem between the table and wall. As is, you can see that the camera was tilted, not the glass. Good attempt. Everything in focus with nice cropping. Like the "coke' glass idea. Still worth a 7 for the photograph quality.

Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment:
What's the blue on the glass by the cookie? First thing I saw. Good choice of background. Looks like taken with camera at an angle, good job. Great focus and cropping. I like the frame and think it adds to this photo, usually don't. Great job. Would be worth an 8.

A Politically Incorrect Drinking Establishment?
by ChrisW123

Comment:
This is fantastic. You'd have to be from the south to get the full impact. Can't believe you found this. Photo is beautiful also. Nice and clear focus, good lighting, nice composition. I love it. It's worth a 10 to a southern.