Why you.....!!!! Bite me, will you?
by mcrael

Comment:
1)Does the Photo fit the theme?(3)
2)Color(5)
3)Composition(4)
4)Focus(5)
5)Background(4)
6)Lighting(4)
7)Title(5)

Overall Score:4.28 rounded to 4

Commentary:
I do not feel in my oppinion that this picture portrays motion that well.
The background is a bit low key as far as its purpose for this shot.
I am surprised with all the snow that you could not get a good bounce of light into the Darker dogs face. That would have set up a better looking shot. Appears to me that the wrong dog is wearing the harness.

John (TurboTech)

Chopper
by Mieka

Comment:
1)Does the Photo fit the theme?(5)
2)Color(5)
3)Composition(6)
4)Focus(5)
5)Background(6)
6)Lighting(5)
7)Title(4)

Overall Score:5.14 rounded to 5

Commentary:
Personally I feel there is something missing here. I think the picture itself would have fared better with more picture on the left side than the right. It gives a better sense of direction and in turn fits the theme of the challenge a tad bit more. Now was there anything that could have been caught in the background that would have given us a nice blur when the chopper is passing it. I just feel that there is a lacking element. I had several shots just like this one that I was thinking about for this challenge, so I know how hard it is to get a shot like this.

John (TurboTech)

Subway
by stephan

Comment:
1)Does the Photo Meet the Challenge?(8)
2)Color(7)
3)Composition(7)
4)Focus(7)
5)Background(8)
6)Lighting(6)
7)Title(8)

Overall Score: 7.28 rounded to 7

This is a wonderful shot. For the lighting that you had to work with, I think your colors turned out Nicely. Is there any way for you to do custom white balance here. If not then disregard. It just has an unatrual Hue to the overall lighting. Other than that great shot.

How to Scramble an Egg
by indigo997

Comment:
1)Does the photo fit the Theme? (9)
2)Color(7)
3)Composition(8)
4)Focus(8)
5)Bacground(8)
6)Lighting(7)
7)Title(6)

Overall Score: 7.57 rounded to 8

Commentary:
This shot is done very well. I think the nail could have been straight. The idea is just perfect. The black background causes for the perfect amount of contrast here. Wish I would have used a black background myself. Wonderful shot

John (TurboTech)

Snow, Sleet & Freezing Rain
by Diana

Comment:
Does the Photo fit the Challenge (6)
Colors(5)
Composition(5)
Focus(4)
Background(5)
Lighting (4)
Title(3)

Overall Score: (4.57 rounded to 5.0)

I've Got it!
by sulamk

Comment:
1)Does the Photo fit the Challenge? (5)
2)Color:6
3)Composition:6
4)Focus:(5)
5)Background(5)
6)Lighting(6)
7)Does the Title fit the picture? (4)

Overall Score=5.28 Rounded to 5

This dog is not playing fetch as to what I cna see it look. Looks like he is being frightened by this other dog.

Old Mill Spillway
by Gallatin

Comment:
1)Does the Photo meet the challenge?(5)
2)Color:(7)
3)Composition(7)
4)Focus(6)
5)Background(5)
6)Lighting(6)
7)Title Relavance(6)

Overall Score: 6

Commentary:
This is a good photo. The color is good and the compositon is very good. In a different Challenge I would have scored this a little better. Only thing I can suggest is to get down a little furthur if you can. I do not like this much of an angle. Otherwise this is a good good shot.

Broken Motion
by Jacko

Comment:
1)Does this Fit the Challenge? (8)
2)Color:(7)
3)Composition(7)
4)Focus:(5)
5)Background(7)
6)Lighting(7)
7)Does the Title fit Photo:(6)

Overall Score 6.71 rounded to 7

Commentary:
You have done a very good Job here. I like this shot. Good Portrait and I will tell you why. You take notice to the little things. I like the fact that the back of the hands are not showing. You broke the wrists at every stop. Obviously you know Portraits. The light could have been a little lighter but you did get your point across. Wonderful.

Fast Water
by Morgan

Comment:
1)Does the Photo fit the theme:(6)
2)Color:(5)
3)Composition:(7)
4)Focus:(5)
5)Background:(5)
6)Lighting:(4)
7)Relavancy of Title:(7)

Overall Score 5.57 rounded to 6

Commontary:
I do not think this is a bad shot. I am big on geting as close as possible to the focal point. I do believe however that there are some limitations to this theory and I personally do not like it used here. I think to back away a little bit more and get closer to the ground will cause for a more intresting picture. I could be wrong but that is just my oppinion. I think your lines are decent because they lead the eye through the photograph. Decent Job. :-)

Starlight Express
by Natasha

Comment:
1)Does the photo fit the theme? (9)
2)Color:(6)
3)Composition:(7)
4)Focus: (6)
5)Bacground:(7)
6)Lighting:(6)
7)Relavance to the Title:(5)

Overall Score: 6.57 rounded to 7

Commentary: This is an intresting shot to say the least. Curious if the Wheel in
the background is the same as the wheel in the fore and midground
If it is I really need to know how you did this shot. I like this. Very
well thought out.