Tomatoes are good for you
by DistantColours

Comment:
I found the original by IreneM. Your version has a very soft waxed feel to it. The reflections are better controlled in your version. Must have been hard with the reflective fork underneath. Still all those reflections "distort" the round shape of the tomato.

Flora III
by GolferDDS

Comment:
I think it is better than the original and of course a different color. You used a more sculpting light to enhance the shape. Could maybe do with a bit more sharpening.

photographer's eyes see more
by Thamerl

Comment:
Nice soft female touch. It is less intense than the original. To get closer it would need more light in the eye, harsher shadows (less reflection from the left) and a closer square crop. Amazing how the hat is almost exactly the same as the other one in this challenge, the fold, the light spots, etc (except for one small damage).

My Polaroid (by Wildpurple)
by Tiberius

Comment:
This is quite a free interpretation of the original (not emulated as close as possible). The angles are different, the light is, the camera is, the flowers are. The original is much more clean. But what bothers me the most is the dirt around the lens opening.

Drop of Honey (Jacko, #23317)
by hajeka

Comment:
The original has the reflection a bit better controlled, not going through the H, and some more surface tension. Maybe you waited a bit longer after placing the drop. But a good effort anyway. 6 for now.

Beauty And The Beast (Solid Chocolate. Details In Photographer's Comments)
by GolferDDS

Comment:
Wow, what an effort !!! I am just thinking what else you could have used to make the mold. Maybe clay or something from a DIY store? I understand your choice based on experience and availability, but it seems a lot work.

A Glass of Water
by Mona

Comment:
Good subject for the challenge but it could have been photographed differently to express simplicity in a much stronger way. Simpler background, no white spots, reduced reflections/refractions, so just in a much more clean way.

Dune
by ThingFish

Comment:
The almost bald head of an old man.

Over the River
by markwiley

Comment:
Challenge details: Your amazing Landscape photo shall be totally sky-free. That means NO SKY. Not even a mirror reflection of sky in the water.

Rocky Road. Without Chocolate it would just be Gravel.
by jomari

Comment:
The last image I have to comment but I find it difficult. I can see an effort to make something extra out of the subject but it does not appeal to me strongly, probably due to composition and flat light. A more warm atmosphere would have enhanced it I think.