Trains acoming
by benhur

Comment:
This looks like it has good 'pp' potential, maybe. Like the 'smoke/steam' element. Perspective is good, and while difficult or even impossible, an even sharper one, with possibly more height as well, likely give this even more drama in my opinion. Of course not so tight a crop of the 'smoke/steam', but depends on what you had to work with, obviously.

Inca Tern 2
by dsa157

Comment:
Excellent coloring. Might just be the angle/perspective, but looks like it needs a nudge rotation up on the right, but apologies if wrong. 'If only' the beak were a little sharper, make this even better in my opinion. Very nice and complementary background/bokeh.

Stinky flower.jpg
by Cantique

Comment:
Nice capture of this hard to kill lily. The 'black' fly adds an element to this in my opinion. Good colors. The shine/reflection slightly detracts, but minor.

Portrait of Majesty
by Cantique

Comment:
Very nice. Left a more detailed comment on the other version.

Favorite Spot
by Cantique

Comment:
Nice capture. I like the other version also, but there is a little more detail in the eagle in this. Both however, as you know, have a little 'haze', or grain, but probably due to the pp as you mentioned. The other, wall size, I'm sure looks great. Nice scene and composition. The fact that this was taken in the wild makes it even better in my opinion.

"Mom! Dad is trying to make toast again!"
by soccerdad

Comment:
'7' likely - good set up, likely a crop variation (depending what you had to work with of course), to cut out more of the toaster and perhaps include more of the black smoke at the top may have made this better in my opinion.

Honey...Your Drink!
by livitup

Comment:
'5' maybe '6', difficult shot, but focus sharper on the glass/liquid as seems to be on the floor/tiles just in front of it, make this better in my opinion.

oops-IMG_8217.jpg
by Zippy

Comment:
'6' - likely. Difficult, but needs a little more detail. Not having a title doesn't matter so much in a shot like this, but it may have. edit: Just read this is 'Face Plant' from the thread.

DPCCRW1570.jpg
by mpeters

Comment:
'2' or '3', likely - without a title here (although you have one in the thread) makes it more difficult, but most importantly, what is on the spray can is not easily recognizable as 'not deodorant', in my opinion. Other factors in the photo as well, make this have a 'raw' type feel, which detracts, in my opinion.

Dropped Catch !!
by millsa

Comment:
7 - Good .. 'catch'. Color is good. Criticism; difficult, but more detail would have made this better but obviously camera/lens dependent. Depending what you had to work with, perhaps a nudge rotation up on the left and a crop trying to gain more symmetry and get the boundary line 'level', may have made this even better in my opinion. Not sure on the frame, 'works', but at this size perhaps is a little too dominant, again, in my opinion.