Sound Through Scratch
by Magnumphotography

Comment:
6 - I like the colors, the abstractness, the transparency and even the framing - hard to explain, but it seems a little harsh - might be that black area.

Deveined
by macwilyum

Comment:
6 - I like the subject and the shadow element, but wish it were more defined/sharper and the composition slightly different - the angle of the shadow and the angle of the leaf/veined thing (might be a pod), just isn't sitting well - despite the good darker corners to try to balance it out. I quite like your framing too. Just seems out, somehow, but may be different on a different medium/larger.

A Quiet Moment.
by BarbB

Comment:
6 - Maybe it is because of the size constraints, but I wish I could decipher what that orange/yellow thing is. Otherwise, I like the tones and wish this had a little more of a dreamy/fantasy feel overall.

Solo
by BeckyT

Comment:
7 - I like the texture and detail discernible - would like to see more. Compositionally, it seems unbalanced, also seems tilted slightly. I like the tones & light. Up to 7 from 6.

Door
by Retroesque

Comment:
6 - I like the blur effect, but a more refined crop and some tweaking with contrast/something make this better in my opinion.

Aging (from the Sunset Series)
by wheeledd

Comment:
6 - Looks weird enough to warrant 'art' but wonder about either more extreme processing and/or trying to minimize the 'self portrait'/home shot feel to this.

Ophelia's Net Weight
by posthumous

Comment:
6 - I think you won't like this comment, but it seems, visually, like it needs a nudge up on the right to straighten, even for a visual balance. However then the seemingly 'chopped' right hand side would be further accentuated. I especially like the flick up of water down center right.

A Song for Bernadette
by njsabs

Comment:
6 - Nice feel, nice light, nice colors, nice moment, nice title - seeing the distant figures far right takes me back to reality though... A slightly more refined crop at the fore/bottom too, make it stronger in my opinion.

The Lady in the Lamp
by Judi

Comment:
6 - I like the effort, but it is not strange enough (I know) for me - as in, looks too staged, maybe a much bolder crop on the left, to eliminate 'normality', who knows. The compositional balance is also out - what with that lonely lamp on its own on the right there and all. I like that element. Fairly minor, but there seems to need a whisker nudge up on the left.

Water Garden
by love

Comment:
6 - I like this, but wonder about more potential with a more refined crop.