The forgotten carnival mask-Venice 2005
by sarimili

Comment:
This shot has some very strange lighting and is blurry. I feel that this photograph belongs in this challenge like a beautifully composed poem belongs in a corporation's annual report. Your first clue could have been the extra description that you felt needed in the title. There are photo competitions on the internet that allow for submitting your best photo (or a photo of your choice), however, I believe this site is prompting you to take shots that you wouldn't have otherwise by followin the description of the challenge. I hope this comment is constructive. If your photo finishes lower than you had hoped this might be the reason. Good luck.

childhood a treasure in any era
by sasharose

Comment:
I'm going to have my first daughter in 2 months, so in a few years I can see myself trying to capture a shot like this. But, this photograph belongs in this challenge like a beautifully composed poem belongs in a corporation's annual report. There are photo competitions on the internet that allow for submitting your best photo (or a photo of your choice), however, I believe this site is prompting you to take shots that you wouldn't have otherwise by followin the description of the challenge. I hope this comment is constructive. If your photo finishes lower than you had hoped this might be the reason. Good luck.

The Most Amazing Time In Life
by bowronfam3

Comment:
In two months my wife will give birth to my first child. I'm sure I'll be taking many shots like this. But, this photograph belongs in this challenge like a beautifully composed poem belongs in a corporation's annual report. There are photo competitions on the internet that allow for submitting your best photo (or a photo of your choice), however, I believe this site is prompting you to take shots that you wouldn't have otherwise by followin the description of the challenge. I hope this comment is constructive. If your photo finishes lower than you had hoped this might be the reason. Good luck.

2005 In Bloom
by Ice-Tea-1983

Comment:
I like the photo other than the over exposure. But, this photograph belongs in this challenge like a beautifully composed poem belongs in a corporation's annual report. There are photo competitions on the internet that allow for submitting your best photo (or a photo of your choice), however, I believe this site is prompting you to take shots that you wouldn't have otherwise by followin the description of the challenge. I hope this comment is constructive. If your photo finishes lower than you had hoped this might be the reason. Good luck.

Now - Feel it.
by Apee

Comment:
I'm scorig you quite low for a few reasons. Please take these reasons as a representation of how to please or not please one voter (maybe more if I'm the only one willing to comment) One I have no idea what year you are portraying (by looking at the picture. Although you say "now" in your title, now is not a year and the hands on a clock have been around for a long time, which leads me to... Two, this clock is not something that would do well in a time capsule. It is like you are submitting a photograph to a corporate client hoping they will use your photo in their adds. They ask for a picture the distiguishes which a specific year. Would they select your photo over others. No.

1931
by Ozzie

Comment:
Love everything about this picture except the grass as a background. I think it would have had more punch on cement, concrete, brick, etc. The green seems to be reflecting into the yellow paint effecting the purity of the color.

1978
by saloonstudios

Comment:
This is so close to being absolutely perfect. The crop pulls you in and the depth of field make me feel fine with not being able to see the entire car. So good job there. I notice your reflection. That to me is the only flaw. If only we could clone that out in an open challenge... Great shot!

1969
by 4score

Comment:
Awesome. The posture and expression makes the shot. Can't make his way back into the house without finishing the article. PERFECT.

Year Zero in Rome: Thumb Up Live Thumb Down Die
by ninja

Comment:
WOW. Doesn't look set up with a modern building in the background like many in this competition. This is just perfect. Best I've seen after 100 votes or so.

nineteen-thirty-eight
by bikefreak

Comment:
Love this. The photograph is done in the style of the art of the era.