Medieval View
by love

Comment:
I like the idea, but I think the model should have been a little closer to the window so she would fill the space better. It also looks like the dodge and burn tools were used agressively (at least on my monitor). In any event, the lighting is unusual.

The Church Pews
by Wobble

Comment:
This is a bit busy for my taste. If you hadn't told me they were pews I might not have figured it out. Colors are good. The leaded window is probably a good choice. I think a simpler reflection might have helped this one.

Backyard view
by srdanz

Comment:
The window is framing a lot of stuff here. The composition might be improved if a few of the foreground items were removed and the windo did not cut throught the woman's back.

The vase
by train

Comment:
Good clear picture. Perhaps a bit more detail in the vase and flowers would be better (another light source perhaps). I like the simple composition.

Angel under glass
by lahern

Comment:
This photo is a bit busy for my taste. Other objects in the glass compete with the angel for attention. Personally, I think that reflective pictures are difficult because lines appear fuzzy (I know, because I did the same kind of thing for this challenge with similar results).

Nikki
by facesastheycome

Comment:
I would try to tone down the background lighting a bit. I think it overpowers a very attractive model. I like the composition and "feel" of the photo.

Window magic
by max90034

Comment:
This photo is a bit hard to follow. There is so much blurring that I am a bit disoriented. I assume this is a stained glass window, but I am not sure. Other than that the picture is crisp, well-framed, and an overall creative effort.

Elements of Reality
by karmat

Comment:
I like the concept of this picture. For me, however, the reflection of the truck is a bit of a distraction (even if the truck is the reason she is at the door). Otherwise, it is done well. Cute model, BTW.

Bonjour!
by ClubJuggle

Comment:
This is a nice effort, but I think the white background is a little too washed out. Makes it hard to see the details such as the stem on the glass. Over all, though, it shows some thought and expression. It is especially good if you are both the photographer and the model.

OUCH! Sharp
by tngrndream

Comment:
I didn't vote in this challenge because of family commitments, but if I had I probably would have given it a 4 or 5. While I like the idea and I think it would be fun to stage this photo, it seems to me that the execution doesn't quite carry it off (e.g. the picture cuts off the blood stain but leaves an essentially unnecessary dark background line at the top). I would have cropped out the top and added more to the bottom (you would have to re-shoot to keep your hand in the image, of course). Focus is good. Perhaps some 'blood' on the blade would help too. (BTW, if I seem too 'sharp' with my observations, I need to add that I probably wouldn't have carried this off any better myself.)