Hey!!!! No Pictures
by Transit

Comment:
*Critique Club*

I thought this was great when I saw it during the challenge. I remember scoring it very high. Your DOF is spot on IMO. The colors are wonderful. Technically, I think that it is perfect. I have no idea why it didn't score higher? I guess because there where so many awesome photos in this challenge! It was a real hard one. I love the facial expression. You couldn't have clicked the shutter at a more perfect time. Way to go! Sorry, that I did not have any suggestions for you. When I see photos like yours I wonder if I should really be a part of the "critique club".

Mandy

birra
by Deboh

Comment:
*Critique Club*

What a great collection of coasters! I love how they are just randomly placed...no real order. I think that the picture is in great focus, I know that sometimes the coasters are not printed in sharp tack focus so I didn't hold that against you. The color is a little flat for me also. I would have maybe upped the saturation of color just a little..not too much. Maybe if you had a nice cold beer sitting on one of the coasters it would have made a difference...not sure. Voters seem to like water drops for some reason. I think that you did a great job. I didn't look to see where this picture placed in the challenge but I am sure it was better than mine! LOL

Mandy

Industrial Revolution
by verg

Comment:
*Critique Club*

To me this looks like a dumpster or a train car with a sticker on it. Am I right? I really like the perspective but this doesn't say Industry very clearly. I am not sure what processes you used since you did not list them but I am guessing that you used a filter? The high contrast look makes the image look almost like a cartoon to me. THis picture is much different than the other entries. For me, that is a plus...why take a picture people are going to expect right? That would be boring! I encourage your creativity and to keep entering challenges, however I do not feel that the processes used on this photo flatter it at all. I would love to see the original and other shots that you took that day. Good luck in future challenges and keep being different.

mandy

Holiday Fruit Baskets
by scalvert

Comment:
very nice...congrats on a great picture

Holiday Tanzanite Ice
by LadeeM

Comment:
the red in the background grabs my attention more than the earrings. The color is a little too strong and it also clashes with the purple color of the stones. Nice detail and focus on the earrings though

Antique Coptic Cross with Kyanite Beads
by Germaine

Comment:
nice picture...the bg doesn't really flatter the necklace. A lighter bg would have made those beads POP.

A Day at the Zoo
by Steveinnz

Comment:
I have no idea what this has to do with the Holidays...but nice picture.

When you can't have a Tree, at least you can have a Star
by Pug-H

Comment:
Very cute picture, nice job.

$ 7,99
by hanneke

Comment:
Wouldn't expect to see many bw photos in a catalog. Your picture is wonderful though! For this challenge I would have rather seen it in color...the reflection of the woman in the christmas ball is neat too!

A Feeling Of Christmas
by TUBORG

Comment:
I guess that is your tree in the bg? Great picture.