A new breed
by RedOak

Comment:
Yes yes Yes, finally someone who actually attempted surrealism, and an excellent photo as well. A ten! 10

Fish
by palmfrodur

Comment:
If you moved the sink outside just for the photo, you were on the right track, but your result just looks like a child playing outside in a backyard. Now if she was cutting up a lobster with a hammer and had her face painted like a wild indian, while wearing 20 foot stilts, and had the sink filled with milk and metal bolts, you might have surrealism. Know what I mean? Dreamlike.

Reality Perception
by Tranquil

Comment:
Woah, 10!

Frustration
by Grzi

Comment:
See, a good surreal photo should make me say WTF????? Yours makes me say WTF????? I love it 10! I can't wait until the voting is done so I can see how you did this. Great shot!

Urban Escher
by jdannels

Comment:
Escher wasn't a surrealist, and I don't get surrealism from this picture, but it is such a beautiful shot, so we'll keep the non-surreal part a secret and I'll vote this a 10

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment:
Its nice that your camera picks up clean star images, but c'mon, you could have submitted anything else in black and white, and it would have been closer to something Ansel Adams would have done.

Dear Ansel, im sorry I shamed you in trying to recreate your style. I know I suck.
by jmlelii

Comment:
The only thing that sucks about your photo is the title. Have some confidence! 8

Looking thru
by Nuno

Comment:
Nice B+W photo, but I'm not sure this met the challenge.

Low Tide
by floyd

Comment:
Amazing shot! I'm not sure how Anselie Adamsie this is, but its a great shot! 10

Oak Silhouette
by Pixelstate

Comment:
This could do without the off-white border, but I won't let that hurt my vote. 8 Good darks, but some of the lights could be whiter.