Sunset tree
by birkin

Comment:
very nice curves to tree and sun against the linear lines of structure. nice sky. nice tree. overall pleasing to the senses shot...8 gl in challenge :-)

Big Wall Flower
by michael_p

Comment:
less blur on foreground, even though I feel you did this cause you liked it. perhaps less gradient on sky? The grass right up front..one blade..white/yellow keeps making me look away from the tree. I do feel you met the challenge 5 and nice colours 6 ..so I give your shot a 6..gl in challenge :-)

Plum tree in bud
by Nuzzer

Comment:
the blur behind the buds is nice. wish the mossy part of tree was sharpened more. I do feel you met the challenge even though i had to debate does a bud constitute a tree since the bud is what gets my attention and seems the subject of picture. Taking the bud as a part of the tree I am giving you a 6. 5 on tree and 7 on bud. gl with challenge :-)

Moonshine
by scalvert

Comment:
first thought is to crop out a good deal of the blue sky. I think it detracts from the blue in the boats in lower portion. I do like the stars. However, stars and moon rays and fog of sorts...lot going on. One set of boats very vivid and the boat overturned under tree I almost missed. Seems to be many things gettin my attention other than the tree. gl in challenge :-)

Evening Swim
by amber

Comment:
i'd like to see more detail visible in this tree. Picture does make me feel emotion..primarily..ahhhhhhhh wish I could swim there...tranquility in the city. gl in challenge :-)

First Sprinkle
by SherwinJames

Comment:
first thought on this pic...title of "twinkle twinkle little tree"? I like the light, like the sprinkles the size of leaves and trunk make me think more branch than tree. The polish/sheen on left leaves is good. good luck in challenge 7

Northern Night
by Louis

Comment:
brown or neutral to the grassy area and some green pop to the tree with the nice sky with a swirl of sorts would really appeal to me in this picture. best of luck in challenge :-)

Kitsilano
by seebrown

Comment:
looks to be a weeping willow? contrasts of colors is nice. However, if this is a sunset the blue looks a little harsh. The sun rays, flare are nice...draws me into the picture. I think I would like more detail in the tree rather than just a black shape. gl in challenge :-)

Timid
by elsapo

Comment:
does the name "Jade" for color, luck and beauty fit???congrats

The Three Amigos
by hotpasta

Comment:
Thank you for all your hard work, dedication, and love you give to the children of the world :-)