Trainwheels
by scottaub

Comment:
Subject is clear, form mentioned in assigment is present in multiple variations. I'm not sure the triangle at top adds anything useful. Main areas are quite contrasty, so maybe softer light would have been better.

Let There be Light
by umbris

Comment:
The image is not straight, but exposure is perfect. It's hard to say what's the subject, but immense clarity in detail gives too much to do to concentrate on that problem. Nice one.

SHADES OF GREY
by medinfo2000

Comment:
Light is very nice. Background is too dull, but emphasizes the main subject well. Tones are a bit middle centered, as deeper shadows seem quite full.

Alien Shadow
by wetland

Comment:
Very interesting object with an amazing shadow! Aperture could have been higher to enable complete sharpness everywhere. Light is very sharp on the main object, which makes the shadow better but causes the object to have too deep contrast.

Downtown
by pagarneau

Comment:
Perspective gives feeling of depth, but tones don't highlight that. There're odd contrast areas, like a lamp or something on right at the end of some lever, producing silhouette on white area on wall. Main target seems to be missing. People don't seem to add interest, as they're partly blurred to the background in their repeating tones and partly because they are like out of place of function.

lonely shelter
by petrakka

Comment:
Nice silhouette. Form is there. Upper cloud on sky could make this better image, but is left out too much, and lacks contrast. So it feels not all tones are in right places.

Hayden Falls
by xtabintun

Comment:
Deep contrast, but not too many tones in shadows or highlights. Maybe less contrasty version on middle tones would work better.