They Can't Here Us Up Here
by dwolff

Comment:
Well, not a bad idea for a shot for this challenge but it´s framed a little bit too tight for my taste, you cut off the "basket" of the blimp on the left and that really hurts the image IMHO. Also, there seems to be a very wierd blur on the left side of the photo, was it something you did in PP or is your lens just this soft on the left side? 5 from me as I like the idea but not terribly fond of the outcome.

Paranoia
by gloda

Comment:
Nice lighting, did you paint this one with light or how did you get that subtle lighting on the couch she is sitting on. Nicely done. However, this isn´t a breathtaking photograph so I "only" gave it a 7 but one of the better ones in the challenge.

The bass player
by geimdrengur

Comment:
Congratulations on getting a blue ribbon with this pretty cool shot and your first entry to boot! Oh and just for the record, about 2 weeks ago I encouraged Kiddi to start participating in challenges here at DPC as I thought he had what it took to be a ribbon winner.

Me and my stupid big mouth... I would have gotten the 13th place if I would have just kept it shut

Magritte Shoes
by Oded

Comment:
Validated or not, I just don´t care at all for the post processing. If you like it, keep it up though cause what the hell do I know though but I thought you deserved an explanation as to why I only gave it a 3 and that´s mainly just because you are on topic.

Detached
by e301

Comment:
Nice candid, I love the tones and contrast in this one, gave it an 8.

Stilettos (Too Sharp)
by Qart

Comment:
Nice, I love the idea and outcome, only thing I don´t really care for is the lighting making shadows or bright areas as the light is reflected up again on her feet. One of the best shots in the challenge, I gave it a 8.

Ant's Nightmare
by owen

Comment:
Nice idea and pretty well executed, I think I would have liked it slightly more if the proportions were more 50/50, I mean the sole the left 50% of the frame and the person the right 50% of the frame. One of the better shots in the challenge, mainly because of orignality and I gave it a 7.

Neighbor's Tales
by Car54

Comment:
I suggest you try and make the most of the file size of 150kb your image can be next time you enter a challenge as this one has some bad artefacts due to severe image compression.

divorced...
by taterbug

Comment:
Excellent colour cast and I like the composition but the title doesn´t really fit with the image IMHO, at least I don´t get it... 7 from me.

do a little dance
by mycelium

Comment:
Nice, but I think I would have liked it a whole lot more with some slight motion blur on the shoes itself, I find the image a bit static as it is. Love the colours and the whole setting and one of the better shots in the challenge, 7 from me.