A Day Gone By
by NstiG8tr

Comment:
Nice sunset, had something similar in mind for this challenge as these shots never fail but the weather didn´t cooperate... Anyway, this is nice but would have been even nicer if there would have been just something in the sky, birds, a cloud, an airplane. Like it as it is though and gave a 7.

Lost In Time
by insteps

Comment:
Very impressionistic, I love it, especially the colours that are deep and full but not oversaturated. Gave this a 7.

The Child Goddess
by Judi

Comment:
I thought this challenge was without mirrors and as far as I can see she is sitting on one. Well I will of course give you the benefit of the doubt regarding that but I have a feeling this is getting a lot of "off topic" comments. Anyway, like this shot but still there is something missing. Also could use a wider tonal range, there are a couple of spots on the dress that are blown out.

The Farmer's Pond
by fixedintime

Comment:
Looks a bit oversharpened on my screen, there is a very distinctive halo around just about everything in the shot but otherwise I like this shot, fitting for the theme and the composition is good. 6 from me.

Forest Impressions
by docurrie

Comment:
Nice idea with the panning but it´s not pronounced enough for my taste, I would have either liked this to be completely frozen or panned more, it´s somewhere in between as it is. Anyway, fitting for the challenge and I like the colours so I gave this a 6.

Lakeside Sunset
by ibkc

Comment:
Nice, nothing we haven´t seen before but it looks good, great reflection considering you didn´t do any spot editing, I think this would look even cooler if you could have enhanced the reflection in the eye. 6 from me.

Window Reflections
by KarenNfld

Comment:
Cool, very artsy, love the composition and colours, gave this a 7.

'Celebrate the love of your life'
by terje

Comment:
Pretty cool shot and love the effect, great idea! If you ever do a reshoot I would suggest having someone on this side of the train too that is standing still and looking "through" at the couple, I think that would completely nail this shot but I completely like this as it is, I gave this a 9.

It's Official
by cbeller

Comment:
A nice candid shot, just two things I would have liked better if they were otherwise and that is that I would have preferred if one of the faces were also in the DOF and not just the hand and also if the whole head of the bride were in the frame. Other than that though this is a nice candid shot and I think you made a good choice making this sepia and it´s very fitting for the challenge. 7 from me.

Celebrating a place to worship.
by drz01

Comment:
Nice, spot on exposure and good colours, contrast, sharpness and the works. However, I simply don´t understand why you cut off the top of this building? I pretty much equivalent that with cutting off a persons head in a portrait, well maybe not that bad but still very bad. I still gave this shot a 6 though but if there had been the top of the building in the shot and a little more space over it I would probably have given this a 7.